search

hashicorp / terraform-provider-azurerm

Terraform provider for Azure Resource Manager
https://registry.terraform.io/providers/hashicorp/azurerm/latest/docs
Mozilla Public License 2.0
4.53k stars 4.6k forks source link

hdinsight: support for User Assigned Identities #14846

Open brucema-cloud opened 2 years ago

brucema-cloud commented 2 years ago

Hi team. I saw there is an independent identity block in the ARM API for Microsoft.HDInsight clusters 2021-06-01, https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/templates/microsoft.hdinsight/2021-06-01/clusters?tabs=json image And I can also set the identity in the portal independently like below. image But there is no independent identity block in terraform azurerm_hdinsight_spark_cluster and azurerm_hdinsight_hbase_cluster, I only set the user assigned Identity in the block security_profile, but the security_profile block is not needed for me. Is it possible to add an independent identity block?

Thank you.

aristosvo commented 2 years ago

Hi @brucema-cloud! Thanks for raising this issue.

I believe it is possible to assign a user assigned identity to both azurerm_hdinsight_spark_cluster and azurerm_hdinsight_hbase_cluster by using storage_account_gen2.managed_identity_resource_id. This assignes the user assigned identity to both the underlying storage and the cluster.

Does this solve your problem?

brucema-cloud commented 2 years ago

Hi @aristosvo! Thanks for answering this question. I think you are right, but if I want to use storage_account rather than storage_account_gen2, there is no way to assign a user-assigned identity to the cluster. If I use portal or ARM templates, I can do it.

aristosvo commented 2 years ago

@brucema-cloud Would that help your use-case? I can look into implementing it, but I'd be sure it is used :)

brucema-cloud commented 2 years ago

@aristosvo yes, it is very helpful for my use case. Due to cost and organizational policy constraints, I can only use storage_account， because I can assign an identity to the cluster using the portal or ARM templates and does not need to depend on storage_account_gen2, If terraform can have consistent functionality, it makes a lot of sense.:)

brucema-cloud commented 2 years ago

Hi @aristosvo is there any update?😊

brucema-cloud commented 2 years ago

Hi @aristosvo It is necessary to support User Assigned Identities outside the storage_account_gen2 block. Another use case of mine is to access KeyVault in HDInsight to obtain Secret, I need to give the User Assigned Identities required access policy in my Key vault.

MartinKosicky commented 1 month ago

ble to assign a user assigned identity to both azurerm_hdinsight_spark_cluster and azurerm_hdinsight_hbase_cluster by using storage_account_gen2.managed_identity_resource_id. This assignes the user assigned identity to both the underlying storage and the cluster.

Does this solve your problem?

I wonder if this also gives me ability to access diferent azure services from the HDInsight cluster. Because it seems that I cannot connect to kafka, but im not sure if it's this