Diffs Not Matching Apply - Reporting Per Instructions in Output

[gamename]

tennis@tennisMBP: ~/Documents/inf-catalog/terraform (postgres|✗…)

./tf apply aws_vpc.catalog: Creating... cidr_block: "" => "10.0.0.0/16" default_network_acl_id: "" => "" default_security_group_id: "" => "" enable_dns_hostnames: "" => "1" enable_dns_support: "" => "1" main_route_table_id: "" => "" tags.#: "" => "2" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "catalog" aws_vpc.catalog: Creation complete aws_security_group.rethinkdb_cluster: Creating... description: "" => "allow rethinkdb cluster traffic" ingress.#: "" => "1" ingress.1558883644.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "0" ingress.1558883644.from_port: "" => "29015" ingress.1558883644.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.1558883644.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.1558883644.self: "" => "1" ingress.1558883644.to_port: "" => "29015" name: "" => "rethinkdb_cluster" owner_id: "" => "" tags.#: "" => "1" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_security_group.postgresdb_cluster: Creating... description: "" => "allow postgresdb cluster traffic" ingress.#: "" => "4" ingress.1712012281.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "0" ingress.1712012281.from_port: "" => "22" ingress.1712012281.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.1712012281.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.1712012281.self: "" => "1" ingress.1712012281.to_port: "" => "22" ingress.2450194534.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "0" ingress.2450194534.from_port: "" => "-1" ingress.2450194534.protocol: "" => "icmp" ingress.2450194534.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.2450194534.self: "" => "1" ingress.2450194534.to_port: "" => "-1" ingress.3631810329.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "0" ingress.3631810329.from_port: "" => "5432" ingress.3631810329.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.3631810329.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.3631810329.self: "" => "1" ingress.3631810329.to_port: "" => "5432" ingress.517408620.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "0" ingress.517408620.from_port: "" => "7789" ingress.517408620.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.517408620.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.517408620.self: "" => "1" ingress.517408620.to_port: "" => "7789" name: "" => "postgresdb_cluster" owner_id: "" => "" tags.#: "" => "1" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.private_subnets.2: Creating... availability_zone: "" => "us-east-1e" cidr_block: "" => "10.0.128.0/19" tags.#: "" => "2" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "private_2" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.private_subnets.1: Creating... availability_zone: "" => "us-east-1d" cidr_block: "" => "10.0.64.0/19" tags.#: "" => "2" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "private_1" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.private_subnets.0: Creating... availability_zone: "" => "us-east-1a" cidr_block: "" => "10.0.0.0/19" tags.#: "" => "2" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "private_0" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.public_subnets.2: Creating... availability_zone: "" => "us-east-1e" cidr_block: "" => "10.0.160.0/20" map_public_ip_on_launch: "" => "1" tags.#: "" => "2" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "public_2" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.public_subnets.1: Creating... availability_zone: "" => "us-east-1d" cidr_block: "" => "10.0.96.0/20" map_public_ip_on_launch: "" => "1" tags.#: "" => "2" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "public_1" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.public_subnets.0: Creating... availability_zone: "" => "us-east-1a" cidr_block: "" => "10.0.32.0/20" map_public_ip_on_launch: "" => "1" tags.#: "" => "2" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "public_0" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_internet_gateway.gw: Creating... vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_security_group.external_ssh_access: Creating... description: "" => "allow ssh to nat instances from outside" ingress.#: "" => "1" ingress.2551330357.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "2" ingress.2551330357.cidr_blocks.0: "" => "98.240.50.117/32" ingress.2551330357.cidr_blocks.1: "" => "67.177.166.184/32" ingress.2551330357.from_port: "" => "22" ingress.2551330357.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.2551330357.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.2551330357.self: "" => "0" ingress.2551330357.to_port: "" => "22" name: "" => "external_ssh_access" owner_id: "" => "" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_internet_gateway.gw: Creation complete aws_security_group.nat: Creating... description: "" => "allow internet traffic" ingress.#: "" => "3" ingress.32090245.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "1" ingress.32090245.cidr_blocks.0: "" => "0.0.0.0/0" ingress.32090245.from_port: "" => "-1" ingress.32090245.protocol: "" => "icmp" ingress.32090245.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.32090245.self: "" => "0" ingress.32090245.to_port: "" => "-1" ingress.328410206.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "1" ingress.328410206.cidr_blocks.0: "" => "0.0.0.0/0" ingress.328410206.from_port: "" => "0" ingress.328410206.protocol: "" => "udp" ingress.328410206.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.328410206.self: "" => "0" ingress.328410206.to_port: "" => "65535" ingress.4092576624.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "1" ingress.4092576624.cidr_blocks.0: "" => "0.0.0.0/0" ingress.4092576624.from_port: "" => "0" ingress.4092576624.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.4092576624.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.4092576624.self: "" => "0" ingress.4092576624.to_port: "" => "65535" name: "" => "nat" owner_id: "" => "" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.private_subnets.2: Creation complete aws_security_group.load_balancer: Creating... description: "" => "allow incoming http traffic" ingress.#: "" => "1" ingress.2603706321.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "1" ingress.2603706321.cidr_blocks.0: "" => "0.0.0.0/0" ingress.2603706321.from_port: "" => "80" ingress.2603706321.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.2603706321.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.2603706321.self: "" => "0" ingress.2603706321.to_port: "" => "80" name: "" => "load_balancer" owner_id: "" => "" tags.#: "" => "1" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.private_subnets.0: Creation complete aws_security_group.consul_agent: Creating... description: "" => "allow all consul agent tcp traffic" ingress.#: "" => "2" ingress.267550030.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "1" ingress.267550030.cidr_blocks.0: "" => "10.0.0.0/16" ingress.267550030.from_port: "" => "8301" ingress.267550030.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.267550030.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.267550030.self: "" => "0" ingress.267550030.to_port: "" => "8301" ingress.983294917.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "1" ingress.983294917.cidr_blocks.0: "" => "10.0.0.0/16" ingress.983294917.from_port: "" => "8301" ingress.983294917.protocol: "" => "udp" ingress.983294917.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.983294917.self: "" => "0" ingress.983294917.to_port: "" => "8301" name: "" => "consul_agent_tcp" owner_id: "" => "" tags.#: "" => "1" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_security_group.external_ssh_access: Creation complete aws_security_group.consul_server: Creating... description: "" => "allow all consul server traffic" ingress.#: "" => "1" ingress.2077434235.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "1" ingress.2077434235.cidr_blocks.0: "" => "10.0.0.0/16" ingress.2077434235.from_port: "" => "8300" ingress.2077434235.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.2077434235.security_groups.#: "" => "0" ingress.2077434235.self: "" => "0" ingress.2077434235.to_port: "" => "8300" name: "" => "consul_server" owner_id: "" => "" tags.#: "" => "1" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.public_subnets.2: Creation complete aws_route_table.public_routes: Creating... route.#: "" => "1" route.1831747878.cidr_block: "" => "0.0.0.0/0" route.1831747878.gateway_id: "" => "igw-b5aa2bd0" route.1831747878.instance_id: "" => "" tags.#: "" => "2" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "public" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_subnet.private_subnets.1: Creation complete aws_subnet.public_subnets.1: Creation complete aws_security_group.rethinkdb_cluster: Creation complete aws_security_group.postgresdb_cluster: Creation complete aws_subnet.public_subnets.0: Creation complete aws_security_group.nat: Creation complete aws_security_group.internal_ssh_access: Creating... description: "" => "allow ssh from nat instances" ingress.#: "" => "1" ingress.4003479348.cidr_blocks.#: "" => "0" ingress.4003479348.from_port: "" => "22" ingress.4003479348.protocol: "" => "tcp" ingress.4003479348.security_groups.#: "" => "1" ingress.4003479348.security_groups.1467514830: "" => "sg-12b90976" ingress.4003479348.self: "" => "0" ingress.4003479348.to_port: "" => "22" name: "" => "internal_ssh_access" owner_id: "" => "" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_route_table.public_routes: Creation complete aws_route_table_association.public.2: Creating... route_table_id: "" => "rtb-dbcd98be" subnet_id: "" => "subnet-f2d793c8" aws_route_table_association.public.1: Creating... route_table_id: "" => "rtb-dbcd98be" subnet_id: "" => "subnet-513da026" aws_route_table_association.public.0: Creating... route_table_id: "" => "rtb-dbcd98be" subnet_id: "" => "subnet-4a8a3713" aws_security_group.load_balancer: Creation complete aws_security_group.consul_server: Creation complete aws_security_group.consul_agent: Creation complete aws_route_table_association.public.2: Creation complete aws_route_table_association.public.1: Creation complete aws_route_table_association.public.0: Creation complete aws_security_group.internal_ssh_access: Creation complete aws_instance.nat: Creating... ami: "" => "ami-921359fa" availability_zone: "" => "" block_device.#: "" => "" iam_instance_profile: "" => "catalog_api" instance_type: "" => "t2.micro" key_name: "" => "tennis" private_dns: "" => "" private_ip: "" => "" public_dns: "" => "" public_ip: "" => "" security_groups.#: "" => "4" security_groups.1141206176: "" => "sg-1eb9097a" security_groups.1467514830: "" => "sg-12b90976" security_groups.1965728998: "" => "sg-17b90973" security_groups.895660234: "" => "sg-1cb90978" source_dest_check: "" => "0" subnet_id: "" => "subnet-4a8a3713" tags.#: "" => "3" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "nat_0" tags.Role: "" => "nat" tenancy: "" => "" aws_launch_configuration.rethinkdb_server: Creating... associate_public_ip_address: "" => "0" image_id: "" => "ami-921359fa" instance_type: "" => "t2.small" key_name: "" => "tennis" name: "" => "rethinkdb_server" security_groups.#: "" => "3" security_groups.1141206176: "" => "sg-1eb9097a" security_groups.787025867: "" => "sg-10b90974" security_groups.895660234: "" => "sg-1cb90978" aws_instance.postgres.1: Creating... ami: "" => "ami-921359fa" availability_zone: "" => "" block_device.#: "" => "1" block_device.3121104763.delete_on_termination: "" => "1" block_device.3121104763.device_name: "" => "/dev/xvdf" block_device.3121104763.encrypted: "" => "" block_device.3121104763.snapshot_id: "" => "" block_device.3121104763.virtual_name: "" => "" block_device.3121104763.volume_size: "" => "10" block_device.3121104763.volume_type: "" => "" iam_instance_profile: "" => "catalog_api" instance_type: "" => "t2.micro" key_name: "" => "tennis" private_dns: "" => "" private_ip: "" => "" public_dns: "" => "" public_ip: "" => "" security_groups.#: "" => "3" security_groups.1141206176: "" => "sg-1eb9097a" security_groups.4288230633: "" => "sg-11b90975" security_groups.895660234: "" => "sg-1cb90978" source_dest_check: "" => "0" subnet_id: "" => "subnet-503da027" tags.#: "" => "3" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "postgres_1" tags.Role: "" => "postgresdb_servers" tenancy: "" => "" aws_instance.postgres.0: Creating... ami: "" => "ami-921359fa" availability_zone: "" => "" block_device.#: "" => "1" block_device.3121104763.delete_on_termination: "" => "1" block_device.3121104763.device_name: "" => "/dev/xvdf" block_device.3121104763.encrypted: "" => "" block_device.3121104763.snapshot_id: "" => "" block_device.3121104763.virtual_name: "" => "" block_device.3121104763.volume_size: "" => "10" block_device.3121104763.volume_type: "" => "" iam_instance_profile: "" => "catalog_api" instance_type: "" => "t2.micro" key_name: "" => "tennis" private_dns: "" => "" private_ip: "" => "" public_dns: "" => "" public_ip: "" => "" security_groups.#: "" => "3" security_groups.1141206176: "" => "sg-1eb9097a" security_groups.4288230633: "" => "sg-11b90975" security_groups.895660234: "" => "sg-1cb90978" source_dest_check: "" => "0" subnet_id: "" => "subnet-4b8a3712" tags.#: "" => "3" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "postgres_0" tags.Role: "" => "postgresdb_servers" tenancy: "" => "" aws_launch_configuration.load_balancer: Creating... associate_public_ip_address: "" => "0" image_id: "" => "ami-921359fa" instance_type: "" => "t2.micro" key_name: "" => "tennis" name: "" => "load_balancer" security_groups.#: "" => "3" security_groups.1141206176: "" => "sg-1eb9097a" security_groups.2248688876: "" => "sg-13b90977" security_groups.895660234: "" => "sg-1cb90978" aws_launch_configuration.consul_launch_configuration: Creating... associate_public_ip_address: "" => "0" image_id: "" => "ami-921359fa" instance_type: "" => "t2.micro" key_name: "" => "tennis" name: "" => "consul_launch_configuration" security_groups.#: "" => "3" security_groups.1141206176: "" => "sg-1eb9097a" security_groups.2277686994: "" => "sg-1db90979" security_groups.895660234: "" => "sg-1cb90978" aws_launch_configuration.consul_launch_configuration: Creation complete aws_launch_configuration.load_balancer: Creation complete aws_launch_configuration.rethinkdb_server: Creation complete aws_instance.nat: Creation complete aws_route_table.private_routes: Creating... route.#: "" => "1" route.4261326527.cidr_block: "" => "0.0.0.0/0" route.4261326527.gateway_id: "" => "" route.4261326527.instance_id: "" => "i-4d8e33a2" tags.#: "" => "2" tags.Environment: "" => "testing" tags.Name: "" => "private" vpc_id: "" => "vpc-831e65e6" aws_instance.postgres.0: Creation complete aws_route_table.private_routes: Creation complete aws_route_table_association.private.2: Creating... route_table_id: "" => "rtb-b1cd98d4" subnet_id: "" => "subnet-f3d793c9" aws_route_table_association.private.1: Creating... route_table_id: "" => "rtb-b1cd98d4" subnet_id: "" => "subnet-503da027" aws_route_table_association.private.0: Creating... route_table_id: "" => "rtb-b1cd98d4" subnet_id: "" => "subnet-4b8a3712" aws_route_table_association.private.2: Creation complete aws_route_table_association.private.0: Creation complete aws_route_table_association.private.1: Creation complete aws_instance.postgres.1: Creation complete Error applying plan:

aws_autoscaling_group.consul: diffs didn't match during apply. This is a bug with the resource provider, please report a bug.

Terraform does not automatically rollback in the face of errors. Instead, your Terraform state file has been partially updated with any resources that successfully completed. Please address the error above and apply again to incrementally change your infrastructure. tennis@tennisMBP: ~/Documents/inf-catalog/terraform (postgres|✗…)

[mitchellh]

Can you reproduce this and run with TF_LOG=1 and attach the debug output please? Thanks!

[gamename]

ok. will do

[gamename]

https://gist.github.com/phinze/527c07732633b355716c

[gamename]

updated. Can't figure out how to clear the "waiting-response" flag - or if I should.

[phinze]

Hey @gamename - just updated your comment to move the debug log into a gist for easier reading :+1:

[phinze]

Notable snippet from the debug log:

-  "vpc_zone_identifier.552724211":*terraform.ResourceAttrDiff{Old:"", New:"74D93920-ED26-11E3-AC10-0800200C9A66,74D93920-ED26-11E3-AC10-0800200C9A66,74D93920-ED26-11E3-AC10-0800200C9A66", NewComputed:false, NewRemoved:false, NewExtra:interface {}(nil), RequiresNew:true, Type:0x0},
+  "vpc_zone_identifier.1236368468":*terraform.ResourceAttrDiff{Old:"", New:"subnet-3ff04c66,subnet-6aa73b1d,subnet-d980c7e3", NewComputed:false, NewRemoved:false, NewExtra:interface {}(nil), RequiresNew:true, Type:0x0},

[mitchellh]

Ah, this is fixed in core. That diff means that a splat is being used at a top level. We now validate against that. :) Can you show me your config @gamename and I can point it out (probably)?

[gamename]

@mitchellh Here's the config with splatting: https://gist.github.com/gamename/21464696d3a26bfc823f

[ghost]

I'm going to lock this issue because it has been closed for 30 days ⏳. This helps our maintainers find and focus on the active issues.

If you have found a problem that seems similar to this, please open a new issue and complete the issue template so we can capture all the details necessary to investigate further.