search

haskell / haskell-ide-engine

The engine for haskell ide-integration. Not an IDE
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
2.38k stars 211 forks source link

We need a logo #267

Closed alanz closed 6 years ago

alanz commented 7 years ago

Which can show up as the extension icon in vscode, among other places.

nponeccop commented 6 years ago

I'm a non-native speaker and to me hie looks just another short name in /bin not used elsewhere :)

garethrowlands commented 6 years ago

@nponeccop I think hie is perfectly reasonable as the name for the binary. I was just trying to justify my preference for a graphic in the logo rather than the acronym. Sorry if I sounded rude. (I posted under gareth-rowlands-akqa).

damienflament commented 6 years ago

The new poll is available here: http://freeonlinesurveys.com/p/Cw1FRJ2G?qid=1017541

nponeccop commented 6 years ago

I wonder if we should make a second tour among 1-5-7 :) or we should declare 7 the winner. The poll doesn't make it clear which is which either.

damienflament commented 6 years ago

@nponeccop This poll is not specifically made for images. But it does not resize images (contrary to the previous one).

image

ismailmustafa commented 6 years ago

Perhaps we should run the same poll again, but this time advertise it on reddit and IRC. I don’t think ~50 votes is very representative of the community. Also, @damienflament’s upgraded logo didn’t make it into this poll.

alanz commented 6 years ago

I think we should wait for the festive season to be over too, and then run it. So in about a week.

damienflament commented 6 years ago

@ismailmustafa If your talking about the logo variation I introduced in this comment, I made it to show it to the community. But it's not my favourite. As it didn't get any upvote neither here nor on Reddit, I didn't add it to the poll.

About advertisement, I added a comment to the original Reddit post and sent an email to the Haskell-cafe mailing list.

damienflament commented 6 years ago

What do we do about this poll ? Currently, it got only 98 voters.

alanz commented 6 years ago

I see #7 got 47% of the vote, which iirc is the one that won the first round too?

In which case it is the winner, and we start updating the README etc to use it.

damienflament commented 6 years ago

I closed the poll as nobody voted since January, 3rd.

Here the results:

Total votes: 168 Total voters: 97

Rank Index Preview Votes Rate (%)
1 7 image 47 27.98
2 5 image 29 17.36
3 1 image 26 15.48
4 2 image 22 13.10
5 6 image 19 11.31
6 4 image 13 7.74
7 3 image 12 7.14
Total 168 100
alanz commented 6 years ago

So we go with the top one, it won the prior round too.

There were some nice options there, I must say. Thanks to all who submitted candidates.

damienflament commented 6 years ago

I uploaded the SVG file and some PNG exports to this gist.

alanz commented 6 years ago

Could you make a PR, that adds a directory called logos with those in it?