hbz / lobid-resources

Transformation, web frontend, and API for the hbz catalog as LOD
http://lobid.org/resources
Eclipse Public License 2.0
7 stars 7 forks source link

Linked "Bände" and "Enthält" are not in GUI ALMA #1992

Open TobiasNx opened 2 months ago

TobiasNx commented 2 months ago

Aleph-Lobid has: grafik http://aleph.lobid.org/resources/HT001387709

ALMA Lobid is missing it: grafik

http://lobid.org/resources/990054089950206441

TobiasNx commented 2 months ago

The linking in ALMA seems to work in our example via ZDB-ID.

TobiasNx commented 2 months ago

With the changing ID in context of ALMA also the linking did change. Links still use the "old" HT-Number as connecting link. But all ZDB publication are now using the zdbId instead of the HT-Number. This results in empty links for Bände and Beiträge.

Bände works in ALEPH with: http://aleph.lobid.org/resources/search?q=isPartOf.hasSuperordinate.id%3A%22http%5C%3A%5C%2F%5C%2Flobid%5C.org%5C%2Fresources%5C%2FHT001387709%23%21%22

In ALMA this results in Zero: http://lobid.org/resources/search?q=isPartOf.hasSuperordinate.id%3A%22http%5C%3A%5C%2F%5C%2Flobid%5C.org%5C%2Fresources%5C%2FHT001387709%23%21%22

When using the ZDB-ID instead of the HT Nr it works. http://lobid.org/resources/search?q=isPartOf.hasSuperordinate.id%3A%22http\%3A\%2F\%2Flobid\.org\%2Fresources\%2FZDB-204679-9%23!%22

Same is true with Beiträge links: http://lobid.org/resources/search?q=containedIn.id%3A%22http\%3A\%2F\%2Flobid\.org\%2Fresources\%2FZDB-204679-9%23!%220

acka47 commented 2 months ago

I was curious how this looks in NWBib because it couldn't be that the problem also exists there. And I was right, these are in NWBib, see https://nwbib.de/search?size=100&t=MultiVolumeBook. Also, looking at some examples, the links to the volumes seem to work with an hbz ID, see e.g. https://nwbib.de/99372656939806441

However I could not find an issue or PR that addressed this over at hbz/nwbib. (We could copy the solution over, then.) However, we are generally using lobid-resources UI fpr debugging puproses only and do not aim at having a fully functioning and complete UI as in NWBib. The official UI for the hbz union catalogue – also based on lobid data –is at https://nrw.digibib.net/search/hbzvk. So these things are low priority.