Open acka47 opened 8 years ago
Sub-issue for #161 .
The persons of 521-1.r
should be added to responsibilityStatement
. Most of the titles of 521-1.t
originate from publishedScores. Also most of the titles in the test set are titles of parts of that resource (exception HT00835923). 521-1.p
contains mostly descriptions of the medium but sometimes with colons at the end, sometimes without. 521-1.a
should contain "Strukturierte Angaben zum Inhalt" but the contents are anything but structured.
Added title of MAB 521-1.t
as titleOfContainedWork
and MAB 521-1.r
as responsibilityStatement
. See HT018855200 and HT018857620.
For a description of the subfields see page 33 of this BVB documents. First I used dc title but it is defined as "A name given to the resource." and not "a name given to the work". I ignored 521-1.p
and 521-1.a
because the contents are so unstructured and contain different contents.
In https://github.com/hbz/lobid-resources/issues/556#issue-253656189 I suggest to use http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w/P10065 for the name string of the work's creator instead of responsibilityStatement
. Whichever we choose, we should use the same property for both cases.
It probably isn't correct to say a work is part of a "manifestation" or bf:Instance
. Maybe we should use something like containsExampleOfWork
instead of hasPart
...
I agree in regard to http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w/P10065 and bibframe/responsibilityStatement. The description of the latter states that the responsibilities are usually transcribed which they aren't in this case.
containsExampleOfWork
seems to be a good idea. hasPart
is also more generic as it contains physical resources which are part of the resource.
Changes applied to smalltest index. See http://test.lobid.org/resources/HT018857620.json.
By now, we are not sure whether information in 521 should always be structured like in HT018854850 or whether the other examples are also correct according to RDA. If the information is always structured and HT018855200 as well as HT018855186 are incorrectly catalogued we can proceed witht he current morph adjustments.
@ChristophEwertowski will check with cataloging colleagues.
Asked cataloging collegue. According to the "Feldhilfe" of Aleph "Enthält" shouldn't be used (HT018855186). And the longer text (HT018855200) isn't right according to her and the "Feldhilfe" which contains a correct title as an example. As we discussed this on Friday and no changes are necessary, I am assigning the pull request to dr0i.
Removed the deploy
label because of an issue with the PR (hbz/lobid-resources#550).
Some adjustments needed, see https://github.com/hbz/lobid-resources/issues/516#issuecomment-327453698
I set this also to "ready" because this issue is dependent on another issue which isn't solved (#516).
MAB 521 contains similar contents to the work titles from MAB 303t. If we include it MAB 521 into containsExampleOfWork
I suggest to only include it if there are no contents from 303t.
Examples:
HT018855200:
DONE
HT018855186:
DONE
HT018854850: