search

hcayless / P3-processing

1 stars 2 forks source link

No paragraphs in tables, please #32

Closed jcowey closed 2 years ago

jcowey commented 3 years ago

In

https://github.com/hcayless/P3-processing/blob/main/articles/ClaytorSmithWarga_FourPoll_TaxReceiptsTrial_4/ClaytorSmithWarga_FourPoll_TaxReceiptsTrial_4.xml#L110-L113

there are p tags within the table.

                  <cell style="text-align: left;">
                     <p xml:id="p6">a: Romulus (χειριστής) </p>
                     <p xml:id="p7">b: Mysthes (λογευτής)</p>
                  </cell>

Please do not let this happen. In the case of the above article it inserted paragraphs 6 and 7 into the table which made the jump from paragraph 5 to paragraph 8 in the main flow of the article look a little strange.

jcowey commented 3 years ago

In tables we could keep the <p> tags for "paragraphs" but without an xml:id? xml:id would, of course, continue to be used elsewhere for all paragraphs.

lmaylein commented 3 years ago

All paragraphs with an xml:id can be addressed directly in our viewer (persistent url, annotation). Maybe it is better to leave the xml:id there and only prevent the output of the line number in the viewer?