search

henkelmax / sound-physics-remastered

A Minecraft mod that provides realistic sound attenuation, reverberation, and absorption through blocks.
GNU General Public License v3.0
75 stars 24 forks source link

[Question] How to make a house that doesnt echo #139

Closed milkev closed 1 year ago

milkev commented 1 year ago

Issue description I've been using this mod for a while, and exploring the world and going through caves and everything is great. I love how sound bounces around and the echo in caves. The only problem is that i cant seem to make a house that doesnt echo like crazy. Ive tried reducing the reflectivity of wood but it made no difference (i believe) since my floor is made of a stone material. Theres no echo if i make my room fully out of wool or similar low reflectivity materials, but that greatly limits the blocks im able to use to only a handful of niche building blocks.

The echo makes the house feel empty, even ive got lots of stuff in it... it can feel sad sometimes and I'd rather have a solution to this than to disable the mod when im at my base.

Steps to reproduce the issue

  1. build a house / room
  2. make some sound, walk around, open chest, etc
  3. echo sounds extremely similar / the same as caves

Desired behavior I dont want my house to feel echo-y and empty.

Versions

Other mods Can provide if you want, but I dont believe its relevant here.

Screenshots (Optional) image Medal Clip with audio of echoing

henkelmax commented 1 year ago

You can change the reflectivity of the blocks you use in your house in the config.

milkev commented 1 year ago

I only see config options for generic block types like "stone". so if i reduce that, ill no longer have echo in caves too

henkelmax commented 1 year ago

You can add specific block types to that config in the latest version of the mod.

milkev commented 1 year ago

I updated to the latest alpha version on modrinth, I dont see any options in config to add blocks. How do I do that? Edit 3: Found it. you cant do it through mod menu. If this is possible in a future update that would be really cool

Also with the alpha version, i can hear mobs in caves way below my base as if they were right next to me... maybe an issue with my config? I'll try regenerating it and see if that fixes it... Edit: Regenerating configs did not fix this Edit2: Seems to be a mod conflict. I'll find it and make a seperate issue

henkelmax commented 1 year ago

If this is possible in a future update that would be really cool

Unfortunately thats not possible with cloth config.