search

henkelmax / sound-physics-remastered

A Minecraft mod that provides realistic sound attenuation, reverberation, and absorption through blocks.
GNU General Public License v3.0
69 stars 22 forks source link

Sounds that start far away remain attenuated even when approaching the source #47

Closed NatSquared closed 2 years ago

NatSquared commented 2 years ago

Bug description When a long sound is started from behind a wall or corner, it does not de-attenuate properly (high-ends stay damped) when you approach the source of the noise

Steps to reproduce the issue

  1. Find or make a cave-like structure.
  2. Note your current coordinates
  3. run /playsound minecraft:music_disc.pigstep ambient @a [coordinates]
  4. Move behind a corner and notice that the sound continues to play in a way that sounds physically accurate: Low-ends travel through the rock and high-ends are only audible in echoes off the walls
  5. Stop all sounds
  6. Run the same command again, with the same coordinates as before, but remain standing behind the corner: /playsound minecraft:music_disc.pigstep ambient @a [coordinates]
  7. Notice that the high-end is no longer echoing off the walls
  8. Approach the source of the sound

Expected behavior Sound attenutation should be updated periodically as the player moves around in the world

Log files N/A; no crash report

Versions

Other mods

architectury-5.7.28-fabric.jar  kubejs-fabric-1900.5.5-build.27.jar   SimpleDiscordLink-fabric-1.19-1.3.0.jar  
cloth-config-7.0.72-fabric.jar  lithium-fabric-mc1.19-0.8.0.jar       soundphysics-fabric-1.19-1.0.6.jar
entitymodifiers-1.2.0.jar       phosphor-fabric-mc1.19.x-0.8.1.jar    textile_backup-2.4.0-1.19.jar
fabric-api-0.57.0+1.19.jar      rhino-fabric-1802.1.14-build.190.jar  voicechat-fabric-1.19-2.2.47.jar
worldedit-mod-7.2.11-beta-01.jar
henkelmax commented 2 years ago

This is a technical limitation, thats very hard to work around. Thats also the reqson why music discs do not have any effects applied to them.