hhromic / e131-node

Node.js client/server library for the E1.31 (sACN) protocol
Apache License 2.0
28 stars 12 forks source link

Client only sends on 1 network interface #21

Open TimoteusRuotsalainen opened 1 year ago

TimoteusRuotsalainen commented 1 year ago

Currently the client sends multicast on the first interface. If the computer has multiple network cards then it would be good to be able to specify which one is used.

Here is an implementation for setting the interface

// E1.31 client object constructor
function Client(arg, port) {
  if (this instanceof Client === false) {
    return new Client(arg, port);
  }

  if (arg === undefined) {
    throw new TypeError('arg should be a host address, name or universe');
  }

  this.host = Number.isInteger(arg) ? e131.getMulticastGroup(arg) : arg;
  this.port = port || e131.DEFAULT_PORT;
  this._socket = dgram.createSocket('udp4');

  this._socket.bind(5568, () => {
    this._socket.setMulticastInterface('10.50.106.2');
  });
}

Is there any preference in how the default is treated? I think one option could be to keep the current functionality and only bind if the the Client is called with a ip address.

There is a pull request for server that implements similar functionality https://github.com/hhromic/e131-node/pull/7/files

hhromic commented 1 year ago

Hi @TimoteusRuotsalainen, I like your proposed implementation better than #7. Would you prepare a PR that would fix #6 and this issue? I promise to review it and we can merge it asap. Thanks!

Is there any preference in how the default is treated? I think one option could be to keep the current functionality and only bind if the the Client is called with a ip address.

I think best is to make a non-breaking change, so please consider keeping the current behaviour if no specific interface is requested for binding.

TimoteusRuotsalainen commented 6 months ago

Better late than never :smile:

https://github.com/hhromic/e131-node/pull/22

Any comments?