search

hifiberry / hifiberry-os

Linux distribution optimized for audio playback
MIT License
1.01k stars 128 forks source link

DSP13 swaps Left and Right speakers #433

Open bobmoss opened 1 year ago

bobmoss commented 1 year ago

Describe the bug Version 13 of the DSP swaps the left and right speakers over.

HiFiBerryOS version 20230223

HiFiBerry sound card DAC+ DSP

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Go to Sound
  2. Click on DSP Programs
  3. Select and install DAC+ DSP Universal version 13
  4. Start playing music.
  5. Click on Sound
  6. Click On Channels
  7. Move balance slider over to the left.
  8. You will notice that the left speaker volume is reduced
  9. Move balance slider over to the right.
  10. You will notice that the right speaker volume is reduced
  11. Set the balance back to center
  12. Go to the advanced page
  13. Mute speaker A (Left), the right speaker is actually muted.

Expected behavior If you move the balance to the left, the right speaker volume should be reduced. If you mute Speaker A, the left speaker should be muted.

Screenshots

Browser (if applicable)

Additional context Version 12 of the DSP works OK, but shows a warning of "Sampling rate is not defined. Filters can't be controlled".

hifiberry commented 1 year ago

You can fix V12 DSP profile by simply changing "samplerate" to "sampleRate"

There is no fixed left/right mapping to a specific channel. You can route any left/right to any channel. What exactly did you configure? You can see the channel mapping in the advance DSP settings.

bobmoss commented 1 year ago

Thanks for the sampleRate fix, that works.

I didn't configure anything. I've just tested again with a brand new install.

  1. Load DSPV12.
  2. Start playing some music.
  3. Go to sound, channels, slide balance to the left - no sound out of my right speaker (correct).
  4. Load DSPV13.
  5. Go to sound, channels, slide balance to the left - no sound out of my LEFT speaker (wrong).

So without any configuration setup or changes, the Default DSPV12 has the speakers correct, The default DSPV13 swaps left and right speakers.

hifiberry commented 1 year ago

I can't reproduce this here. You might try the latest experimental release with DSP profile v14

/opt/hifiberry/bin/update --experimental

jimipj commented 1 year ago

I stumbled upon a similar problem when I was tinkering with DSP profile v14.

If the profile is installed in the normal way, the channels are correct. However, if I download the same v14 profile from the dspprofiles repo and apply it without any changes using SigmaStudio, the channels are swapped.

This was also with DAC+ DSP.