search

hipspy / hips

Python library to handle HiPS
https://hips.readthedocs.io
12 stars 16 forks source link

Astropy Affiliated Package Review #115

Closed astrofrog closed 6 years ago

astrofrog commented 6 years ago

This package has been reviewed by the Astropy coordination committee for inclusion in the Astropy affiliated package ecosystem.

We have adopted a review process for affiliated package that includes assigning quantitative ‘scores’ (red/orange/green) for different categories of review. You can read up more about this process here. (This document, currently in Google Docs, will be moved to the documentation in the near future.) For each of the categories below we have listed the score and have included some comments when the score is not green.

Functionality/ScopeGeneral%20package
No further comments
Integration with Astropy ecosystemGood
No further comments
DocumentationPartial
We are marking this as partial for now while waiting for the 'More advanced examples' section to be written.
TestingGood
No further comments
Development statusHeavy%20development
No further comments
Python 3 compatibilityGood
No further comments

Summary/Decision: Things are looking good, and this package meets the review criteria for affiliated packages, so we are happy to confirm that we'll be listing your package as an affiliated package! Keep up the good work, and we encourage you to improve on the areas above that weren't “green” yet.

If you agree with the above review, please feel free to close this issue. If you have any follow-up questions or disagree with any of the comments above, leave a comment and we can discuss it here. At any point in future you can request a re-review of the package if you believe any of the scores should be updated - contact the coordination committee, and we’ll do a new review. Note that we are in the process of redesigning the http://affiliated.astropy.org page to show these scores (but not the comments). Finally, please keep the title of this issue as-is (“Astropy Affiliated Package Review”) to make it easy to search for affiliated package reviews in future.

cdeil commented 6 years ago

@astrofrog - Thanks for the review!