search

hku-mars / mlcc

Fast and Accurate Extrinsic Calibration for Multiple LiDARs and Cameras
GNU General Public License v2.0
478 stars 108 forks source link

Question about vpnp cost function #2

Closed RoseWillow closed 2 years ago

RoseWillow commented 2 years ago

Dear author, thanks for your excellent work, but I am puzzled by the vpnp cost function, I did not understand why we need the line direction to compute the matrix V, and the physical meaning of this formula VRV.transpose a9dbc88dd7d6bdc163c148b62cf3a50 Look forward to your reply

ChongjianYUAN commented 2 years ago

Dear author, thanks for your excellent work, but I am puzzled by the vpnp cost function, I did not understand why we need the line direction to compute the matrix V, and the physical meaning of this formula VRV.transpose a9dbc88dd7d6bdc163c148b62cf3a50 Look forward to your reply

微信图片_20211116131731 the line direction can help us build point-to-line residual but not point-to-point residual. Besides, the correct formulation of the point-to-line residual is shown in this picture. There are some minor bugs in the code, but they don't matter much after testing.

RoseWillow commented 2 years ago

Dear author, thanks for your excellent work, but I am puzzled by the vpnp cost function, I did not understand why we need the line direction to compute the matrix V, and the physical meaning of this formula VRV.transpose a9dbc88dd7d6bdc163c148b62cf3a50 Look forward to your reply

微信图片_20211116131731 the line direction can help us build point-to-line residual but not point-to-point residual. Besides, the correct formulation of the point-to-line residual is shown in this picture. There are some minor bugs in the code, but they don't matter much after testing.

Thank you for your reply, but I still don't know how to build point-to-line residuals. Can you tell me the source of the picture in your last reply?

ChongjianYUAN commented 2 years ago

Dear author, thanks for your excellent work, but I am puzzled by the vpnp cost function, I did not understand why we need the line direction to compute the matrix V, and the physical meaning of this formula VRV.transpose a9dbc88dd7d6bdc163c148b62cf3a50 Look forward to your reply

微信图片_20211116131731 the line direction can help us build point-to-line residual but not point-to-point residual. Besides, the correct formulation of the point-to-line residual is shown in this picture. There are some minor bugs in the code, but they don't matter much after testing.

Thank you for your reply, but I still don't know how to build point-to-line residuals. Can you tell me the source of the picture in your last reply?

Sorry, the content in this picture is written by myself, so there is no source. You can refer to the vector projection matrix, then you will know how to build point-to-line residuals.

RoseWillow commented 2 years ago

Dear author, thanks for your excellent work, but I am puzzled by the vpnp cost function, I did not understand why we need the line direction to compute the matrix V, and the physical meaning of this formula VRV.transpose a9dbc88dd7d6bdc163c148b62cf3a50 Look forward to your reply

微信图片_20211116131731 the line direction can help us build point-to-line residual but not point-to-point residual. Besides, the correct formulation of the point-to-line residual is shown in this picture. There are some minor bugs in the code, but they don't matter much after testing.

Thank you for your reply, but I still don't know how to build point-to-line residuals. Can you tell me the source of the picture in your last reply?

Sorry, the content in this picture is written by myself, so there is no source. You can refer to the vector projection matrix, then you will know how to build point-to-line residuals.

OK，thank you very much!