hl7au / au-fhir-base

AU Base FHIR Implementation Guide Source
38 stars 26 forks source link

AU Medicare Prescriber Number Identifier datatype profile - example value for Medicare Prescriber Number doesn't meet namespace format #301

Closed robeastwood-agency closed 4 years ago

robeastwood-agency commented 5 years ago

The AU Base Practitioner Profile has an example value for the Medicare Prescriber Number identifier slice of 453221 - see this line. However, the supporting namespace page defines the format as

The format of the value of the identifier is 8 characters, made up of:

  • 6 digits
  • the seventh character (the location) is alphanumeric
  • the eighth character (the check digit) is alphabetical

Suggest change to 049960CT which is the value for this identifier found in the Heathcare identifier HL7 implementation guide (SA HB 234-2012 - section 16 Medicare Prescriber number, pg 36) as well as found on Grahame Grieve's blog.

Maybe even consider further defining the slice to add an invariant to verify the above format, using something like

value.matches('^([0-9]{6}[A-Za-z0-9][A-Za-z])$'))
brettesler-ext commented 4 years ago

this is not prescriber number format - which is just a number - looks like a Provider Number format which is different

brettesler-ext commented 4 years ago

reviuew in MEDS wg

dionmcm commented 4 years ago

@robeastwood-agency can you check and confirm your suggested change given @oridashi 's comment?

dionmcm commented 4 years ago

At the Meds WG prescriber number comes after you have a provider number and as far as we are aware it is just a number, we're not sure what the scheme is. What @robeastwood-agency has suggested looks like a provider number, not a prescriber number (PBS).

@robeastwood-agency can you review whether this answers/resolves this issue?

dionmcm commented 4 years ago

https://www.mater.org.au/group/careers/files/careers/medical-employees/provider-and-prescriber-numbers.pdf

dtr-agency commented 4 years ago

At the Meds WG prescriber number comes after you have a provider number and as far as we are aware it is just a number, we're not sure what the scheme is. What @robeastwood-agency has suggested looks like a provider number, not a prescriber number (PBS).

@robeastwood-agency can you review whether this answers/resolves this issue?

If the above is true and it is not an eight digit identifier made up of two alphanumeric characters then the registered namespace has this wrong here: http://ns.electronichealth.net.au/id/medicare-prescriber-number/index.html

This needs to be tracked down and resolved.

dtr-agency commented 4 years ago

A prescriber number is not location specific. It is issued by Services Australia (Medicare) to doctors, dentists, optometrists, midwives and nurse practitioners who are approved to prescribe PBS medicines under the National Health Act 1953.

See https://www.pbs.gov.au/info/healthpro/explanatory-notes/section1/Section_1_2_Explanatory_Notes

I think we need to improve the informative material for this identifier type - we should be consistent with the language used from Services Australia and PBS.

dtr-agency commented 4 years ago

Agreement to correct the namespace description and improve the informative material. This is in progress.