eric-jahn
commented
3 years ago This is intentional, in that hmis:livingSituation simply reflects the list in Appendix A, and the Schema doesn't offer validation differentiation between the Current/Prior/Destination phases of Living Situations. This is done for reasons of maintainability and simplicity, and for ease of comparison with the CSV. In general, there are many possible additional validations we could add to the XML Schema to bring it into higher fidelity with the Data Dictionary, but for reasons of simplicity and maintainability, we leave them unchecked.
from HUD AAQ: "According to spec for XML we should use Prior Living Situation (3.917) for Enrollment/LivingSituation
But in the spec https://github.com/hmis-interop/xml/blob/FY2020-latest/doc/HUD_HMIS_XML_Schema_generated_documentation.pdf the list for Prior Living Situation includes not only Prior Living Situation(3.917), but Destination (3.12) and Current Living Situation (4.12)
The below options should be excluded from the enrollment/LivingSituation
12 = Staying or living in a family member’s room, apartment or house - Destination (3.12) 13 = Staying or living with friends, temporary tenure (e.g. room apartment or house) - Destination (3.12) 17 = Other - Current Living Situation (4.12) 22 = Staying or living with family, permanent tenure - Destination (3.12) 23 = Staying or living with friends, permanent tenure - Destination (3.12) 24 = Deceased - Destination (3.12) 26 = Moved from one HOPWA funded project to HOPWA PH - Destination (3.12) 27 = Moved from one HOPWA funded project to HOPWA TH - Destination (3.12) 30 = No exit interview completed - Destination (3.12) 37 = Worker unable to determine - Current Living Situation (4.12) You can find more information about the Prior Living Situation Option List in https://files.hudexchange.info/resources/documents/FY-2022-HMIS-Data-Dictionary.pdf ( Appendix A - Living Situation Option List )"