search

hmmlillian / Neural-Color-Transfer

The source code of "single-reference color transfer" in "Progressive Color Transfer with Dense Semantic Correspondences".
https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.00756
74 stars 8 forks source link

Compared experiment question about Mechrez et al. [2017] #5

Closed Ronales closed 2 years ago

Ronales commented 4 years ago

Dear author,In your paper,I can see the stylized image from your Mechrez et al. [2017] code implementation is this:

NS_seg_50

But I use official implementation is this: paper: Roey Mechrez , Eli Shechtman and Lihi Zelnik-Manor. BMVC 2017. author: Mechrez et al. [2017]

image

high solution output is image

I can find some differences in tree colors(your display is white but the official code is green), meanwhile, some other difference can be found in above-compared images

Did you change some weight or reproduced new code of Mechrez et al. [2017] code?The default weight is : image

Thanks in advance!

hmmlillian commented 3 years ago

@Ronales The results we used to compare with Mechrez et al. [2017] come from the website they provided: https://cgm.technion.ac.il/Computer-Graphics-Multimedia/Software/photorealism/ID679-supp/ (NS+segment+SPE) instead of our own implementation.