Tahoma: Windows and Awnings open/close status reversed

[dennismeng]

Home Assistant release with the issue:

96.0

Last working Home Assistant release (if known): Believe it was 94.x

Operating environment (Hass.io/Docker/Windows/etc.):

Hass.IO Component/platform:

https://www.home-assistant.io/components/tahoma/

Description of problem: When opening rooflight windows and awnings, the state shows as "closed" and vise versa.

Problem-relevant configuration.yaml entries and (fill out even if it seems unimportant):

tahoma:

Traceback (if applicable):

It was mentioned in this #24879

Additional information:

[ghost]

Hey there @philklei, mind taking a look at this issue as its been labeled with a integration (tahoma) you are listed as a codeowner for? Thanks!

This is a automatic comment generated by codeowners-mention to help ensure issues and pull requests are seen by the right people.

[Godtoh]

Same issue here since 0.94....

[dickesW]

Same here: these are the states shown by Home Assistant for every device_class I own:

Entity	State	Attributes
cover.shutter	open	current_position: 0 device_class: shutter
cover.window	open	current_position: 0 device_class: window
cover.awning	open	current_position: 100 device_class: awning

These are the real states (current_position is taken from the VELUX INTEGRA® Control Pad KLR 200):

Entity	State	Attributes
cover.shutter	closed	current_position: 100 device_class: shutter
cover.window	closed	current_position: 0 device_class: window
cover.awning	open	current_position: 100 device_class: awning

[Godtoh]

Not only the state, but the position is reversed too. Same issue...

[DjMoren]

Same problem here. I have 2 awnings. If I check their state inspecting the requests made using directly the application in https://www.tahomalink.com, both are closed at 0 and opened at 100, but in HomeAssistant, one closes at 0 and the other one closes at 100.

For the person who is mantaining this plugin, this is a summary of the things I can see that may help:

io:VerticalExteriorAwningIOComponent

Phisical state	core:ClosureState	core:DeploymentState	Position in HomeAssistant	core:OpenClosedState	State in tahomalink widget	State in HomeAssistant
Fully open	100	-	0	closed	open	open
Fully closed	0	-	100	open	closed	closed

io:HorizontalAwningIOComponent

Phisical state	core:ClosureState	core:DeploymentState	Position in HomeAssistant	core:OpenClosedState	State in tahomalink widget	State in HomeAssistant
Fully open	-	100	100	open	open	open
Fully closed	-	0	0	closed	closed	closed

As we can see in the tables, the special thing to be handled is that the io:VerticalExteriorAwningIOComponent uses a reversed state in tahomalink, but the position to be sent is always the same, 0 to be fully closed and 100 to be fully open.

Disclaimer: I don't know if this is only in my case or it is general in this type of component (io:VerticalExteriorAwningIOComponent). If this is not allways the same, two settings like in zwave configuration would help solving the problem: invert_openclose_buttons and invert_percent.

[wpetit]

Same problem here with device_class: shutter for my rolling shutters.

[medaemon]

I have the issue with my covers and as I'm using map of my flat with images changing on status (open/closed covers) it makes me crazy each time I watch my map, I cannot help a lot sorry but please please reverse the change you made after 0.94 and you will be 🥇 for me :)

[ktpx]

I have two sunilus IO motors, and using this component they operate differently. One closes on open_cover, and the other closes on close, but position is wrong when its closed ( 0).

[Godtoh]

Checked some more, reverted the cover.py to https://github.com/home-assistant/home-assistant/pull/23024

State is good, position is still wrong. State now is open when the covers are open, however the position is 100 while it should be 0.

More to do than just the position.

[psicot]

Hello, same problem here with my roller shutters and my garage door.

Opened/closed states are reversed, while the arrows to open/close are well updated.

States are valid only when the roller shutters are opened between 1 and 99%.

• [reversed state] Garage door closed (0%), displayed as opened in Home Assistant. The bottom arrow is disabled (already closed) and the top arrow is enabled to open it.

  

• [reversed state] Kitchen roller shutter opened (100%), displayed as closed in Home Assistant. The bottom arrow is enabled to close it, and the top arrow is disabled (already opened).

  

• [non reversed state] Another roller shutter opened at 45%, displayed as opened in Home Assistant.

  

[psicot]

I would add that via the homekit integration, the status is only reversed for the garage door, not for the roller shutters.