search

horizontalsystems / unstoppable-wallet-android

A powerful non-custodial multi-wallet for Bitcoin, Ethereum, Binance Smart Chain, Avalanche, Solana and other blockchains. Non-custodial crypto and NFT storage, onchain decentralized exchange, institutional grade analytics for cryptcurrency and NFT markets, extensive privacy controls and human oriented design. Implemented on Kotlin.
https://unstoppable.money
MIT License
902 stars 371 forks source link

TON wallet address is different #7143

Closed arkadym closed 1 month ago

arkadym commented 8 months ago

It is related to #7108 - i did an test: 1) Using Unstoppable created new wallet with 24 words, created BNB, BTC, ETH, ARB, AVAX, TRX, TON to the waller. 2) Took same seed (24 words) imported wallet to TrustWallet - all the addresses are same except TON, somehow TON address is different 3) Took same seed and imported wallet to SafePal - same issue, all is ok except TON. 4) Tried use native ton wallets: MyTonWallet, Toncoin wallet, Tonhub, Tonkeeper, Tonkeeper X. All except Tonkeeper X cannot restore with error 'words are incorrect'. Tonkeeper X - did restore, but address is different, actually all 3 addresses are different.

Concluding in total - TON wallet cannot be restore anywhere outside of Unstoppable. Btw, having TON wallet created i dont remember exactly which app (one of above, mostly it was Toncoin wallet), and can now restore in any of above TON specific wallets. But cannot restore (invalid seed phrase) in any of Unstoppable, TW, SafePal.

What i would be glad is - having something compatible with TON wallets. Creating seed which will work there, allow choose network version...

notpri commented 8 months ago

Also Solana address is different on Trust Wallet.

Unstoppable wallets gives you different address for every transaction for privacy. I love this feature of Unstoppable Wallet.

notpri commented 8 months ago

Also note that the old addresses are linked to your wallet so you can also use the old addresses again and again even if UW shows a new one.

arkadym commented 8 months ago

Did few steps further 1) sent TONs to SafePal - TW and UW cannot see it 2) send TONs to TW - UW can see, SP - cannot (obviously) 3) send TONs to UW - TW can see, SP - cannot. So yet it is confirmed, TW using old EQ address and UW using modern address UQ (prefered) but in fact it is same wallet.

Ticket can be closed, probably to add that somewhere.

Yet still there is an issue with seed compatibility between UW and TON wallets. Would appreciate if that can be done. It could be separate single crypto wallet for TON, like TW when creating/importing wallet it asks if that multi crypto of single crypto wallet.

And yet would be super great to have private key for TRON and TON.

serrq commented 8 months ago

Also Solana has the same problem: it hasn't its own private key. Solana isn't EVM or Bitcoin like chain.

Dianaaiym commented 1 month ago

https://github.com/horizontalsystems/unstoppable-wallet-android/issues/7429