hotosm / imagery-coordination

Coordination of Imagery Requests for HOT Activations and other humanitarian mapping
8 stars 8 forks source link

Limit task size #121

Closed smit1678 closed 6 years ago

smit1678 commented 7 years ago

Feedback from user test: limit task AOI size when creating a new task. It may be helpful when creating tasks for UAVs to limit the size you can create.

This will be difficult to set to one size because of varying capabilities of UAV models, but marking here to discuss and evaluate what makes the most sense.

smit1678 commented 7 years ago

To do: determine reasonable limit for UAVs and satellite imagery

smit1678 commented 6 years ago

@cgiovando what kind of area would you suggest for UAVs versus satellite imagery?

Upon thinking about this more, I think I would suggest that we only display warnings based on if UAV or satellite imagery are the type of collection platform. Hard limitations may make edge cases difficult from a user experience perspective.

sharkinsspatial commented 6 years ago

Displaying different size warning based on product types will require a small change to the API to include the product information from the parent request in the returned task. Not sure how you want to coordinate pull requests across repositories?

smit1678 commented 6 years ago

👍 ok that makes sense; I can help coordinate with you. The staging front-end is a connected to a staging API that is running the develop branch. So we can test deploy there. I can help test anything locally first as well.

sharkinsspatial commented 6 years ago

@smit1678 @cgiovando Do we have a limit in square meters I can use for this? There should be one for UAV and then one for everything else.

cgiovando commented 6 years ago

Hey @smit1678 @sharkinsspatial - I think warning may be OK, but I would not set any arbitrary limit. There are different factors that will impact the capacity of providers to cover AOIs with specific platforms and sensor combinations. Listing some here, then we should look at potentially integrating with flight planning software models for UAVs.

There can be more to add to this list, but I would say for small "individual" daily surveys with standard sensors and ceiling, 1 sqkm AOIs are generally considered large.

smit1678 commented 6 years ago

@cgiovando Yes, exactly why a warning is better than a strict limit. So here's what I propose to start with:

UAV: warning at 1sqkm Satellite imagery: 1000sqkm