search

hugeblank / Bagels_Baking

Yet another Minecraft mod that adds loads of food & functionality
MIT License
6 stars 1 forks source link

Item and Block tagging standardization #43

Open hugeblank opened 2 years ago

hugeblank commented 2 years ago

obligatory xkcd comic

XKCD comic 927

Dearest @ExcessiveAmountsOfZombies, @FoundationGames, and @DawnTeamMC; I was skimming through fabric's discord earlier and came across mention of someone using our mods in a pack. Their one complaint was that there was no integration between them. For example, all of our mods add tomatoes, yet none of them are compatible in recipes. That's really annoying and I feel kinda bad for the end user.

Fortunately (or unfortunately depending on how you look at it), croptopia seems to have mostly set the standard for us! In the coming weeks I'll be putting my items in the c: tags, and I reach out to you all to implore you (or your teams) to do the same. If there are any gray areas as to where an item should go, or what a tag should be named, let's discuss it here. If you want to make issues in your own repos to document progress please tag this issue in it as I'd like to be clued into what's going on in the community.

Cheers!

ExcessiveAmountsOfZombies commented 2 years ago

The fabric wiki is slightly outdated in regards to Croptopia's tags, I (and ayutac) recently finished standardizing to the proper c: tags. you can find them all here

As I support forge I also use sub-directories to match forges convention, and then have my recipes reference the base directory tag. anything marked with #${dependent} is changed to c: or forge: whenever the jar is built.

hugeblank commented 2 years ago

@ExcessiveAmountsOfZombies Thanks! This is a really good reference to go off of. I'll be doing so in the near future. I don't know what happened but I managed to completely miss that you were the dev of Croptopia when writing the initial issue. Regardless, I'm glad I absentmindedly tagged you, as your insight is useful.