huixuant / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

Contradictory/Misleading Message in calendar #7

Open huixuant opened 1 year ago

huixuant commented 1 year ago

The message displayed upon execution of the calendar command says that users can use the event find command with the date to list all events for a particular day.

image.png

However, the event find requires users to specify at least one of event names, start times and end times. This means that there is currently no way for users to use the existing find feature to perform what the app suggested under the display message of the calendar command.

nus-se-bot commented 1 year ago

Team's Response

You are suppose to use event find.

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue response

Team chose [response.Rejected]

Reason for disagreement: I believe that the team has misunderstood the issue.

In my original bug report, I was referring to how the "Tip" in the Program Response message displayed states that users can use the event find command with the date to list all events for a particular day, when this is not actually possible.

Since the event find command requires users to specify at least one of event name, start time and event time, and returns events that match the value(s) provided by the user exactly, the current event find feature does not, in fact, allow users to "list all events in that day" unless the events have the same name, start time and end time. I believe a more accurate description of how the event find feature can complement the calendar feature was stated on page 17 of the User Guide; unfortunately, this was not reflected in the message displayed to the user within the app.

image.png

Therefore, in view that the information conveyed in the Program Response message within the app is not entirely accurate, I stand by my original statement that this is a valid feature flaw.