Closed jacekiwaszko1 closed 2 years ago
There are 724 cases of problem markers that I will not convert (at least initially), because the free-form comment parameter has no spaces (so it is difficult to automatically decide that it is not an actual parameter):
These case represent 12990 instances (the most frequent are listed first).
Including the 12990 that are not being fixed, there are a total of 219082 problem messages: 20779 unique messages, with the most common being:
84012 !LO:TX:t=P:problem:kreska pseudotaktowa
29433 !LO:TX:t=P:problem:mixed beam
12917 !LO:TX:a:t=P:problem:mixed beam
6151 !LO:TUP:a:problem:klamra łukowa
3776 !LO:TX:a:t=P:mixed beam:problem
1859 !LO:TX:a:t=P:problem:kreska pseudotaktowa
1673 !LO:TX:t=P:problem:all\right:global
1555 !LO:TX:a:t=|:problem
1555 !LO:TUP:b:problem:klamra łukowa
1312 !LO:TX:a:t=P:problem:# above
1213 !LO:TX:b:t=P:problem:# below
1028 !LO:TX:a:t=P:problem:mixedbeam
878 !LO:TX:a:t=P:problem: mixed beam
850 !LO:TX:t=P:problem:mixedbeam
767 !LO:TX:b:t=|:problem
661 !LO:TX:t=P:problem:klamra łukowa
642 !LO:TX:t=P:problem:kreska pseudotaktowa:między nutą a kropką
624 !LO:TUP:a:problem:klamra łukowa, kropka zamiast numeru
620 !LO:TX:a:t=P:problem:cauda z lewej strony
565 !LO:TX:t=P:problem:# below
1555 !LO:TX:a:t=|:problem
and
767 !LO:TX:b:t=|:problem
Should be turned into vertical strokes.
Conversion is done with the adjustProblems
PERL script:
It would be good if "problem" notation in layout comments was a bit more formalized.
For now we encode text notes as
!LO:TX:t=P:problem:description of the problem
. It would be useful ifproblem
was treated as a parameter:!LO:TX:t=P:problem=description of the problem
Sample Humdrum encoding:
In conversion to MEI
<annot>
element could be used to store the value ofproblem=
parameter:(This issue is kind of related to #660.)