humdrum-tools / verovio-humdrum-viewer

Verovio Humdrum Viewer
http://verovio.humdrum.org
36 stars 9 forks source link

tool enhancement: `humdrumValidator.js` should catch joining between spines error #892

Open bel28kent opened 2 months ago

bel28kent commented 2 months ago

One error that the humdrumValidator.js script does not seem to catch (and humdrum_.c does not catch it either) is when the join happens between two spines, rather than between two subspines of one global spine.

Here's an example of this error, followed by the kern:

Screen Shot 2024-04-24 at 4 34 26 PM
!!!COM: Scriabin, Alexander
!!!OTL@@FR: Mouvement no 2
!!!OTL@@EN: Movement No. 2
!!!OPR@@FR: Sonate no 4
!!!OPR@@EN: Sonata No. 4
!!!OPS: 30
!!!ONM: 2
!!!ODT: 1903
!!!AGN: Sonata movement
**kern  **kern  **dynam
*clefF4 *clefF4 *
*k[f#c#g#d#a#e#]    *k[f#c#g#d#a#e#]    *
*F#:    *F#:    *
*M12/8  *M12/8  *
=48 =48 =48
*k[f#c#]    *k[f#c#]    *
4r  8EL .
.   8c#J    .
8r  8r  .
8r  8G#XL   .
8r  8A  .
8CC# 8C#    8BJ .
*   *^  *
4.FFFn 4.FFn    4E 4A   8eL .
.   .   8c#J    .
.   8r  8r  .
4.FFF#X 4.FF#X  4.C# 4.E    4B  .
.   .   8E  .
*v  *v  *   *
*   *clefG2 *
=   =   =
*-  *-  *-
!!!system-decoration: {(*)}
!!!filter: flipper -a
!!!RDF**kern: > = above
!!!ENC: Bryan Jacob Bell
!!!END: November 2021 to April 2022
!!!PED: Günter Philipp
!!!PTL: Ausgewählte Klavierwerke (Edition Peters)

Here is the correct version of above:

Screen Shot 2024-04-24 at 4 35 52 PM
!!!COM: Scriabin, Alexander
!!!OTL@@FR: Mouvement no 2
!!!OTL@@EN: Movement No. 2
!!!OPR@@FR: Sonate no 4
!!!OPR@@EN: Sonata No. 4
!!!OPS: 30
!!!ONM: 2
!!!ODT: 1903
!!!AGN: Sonata movement
**kern  **kern  **dynam
*clefF4 *clefF4 *
*k[f#c#g#d#a#e#]    *k[f#c#g#d#a#e#]    *
*F#:    *F#:    *
*M12/8  *M12/8  *
=48 =48 =48
*k[f#c#]    *k[f#c#]    *
4r  8EL .
.   8c#J    .
8r  8r  .
8r  8G#XL   .
8r  8A  .
8CC# 8C#    8BJ .
*   *^  *
4.FFFn 4.FFn    4E 4A   8eL .
.   .   8c#J    .
.   8r  8r  .
4.FFF#X 4.FF#X  4.C# 4.E    4B  .
.   .   8E  .
*   *v  *v  *
*   *clefG2 *
=   =   =
*-  *-  *-
!!!system-decoration: {(*)}
!!!filter: flipper -a
!!!RDF**kern: > = above
!!!ENC: Bryan Jacob Bell
!!!END: November 2021 to April 2022
!!!PED: Günter Philipp
!!!PTL: Ausgewählte Klavierwerke (Edition Peters)