search

hvxl / otmonitor

Monitor tool for the OTGW (http://otgw.tclcode.com/)
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
27 stars 10 forks source link

Correct datatypes for MsgID 30, 38, 78 and 107 #21

Closed BernoldNL closed 11 months ago

BernoldNL commented 1 year ago

Hi Schelte,

Please let me introduce myself first. I wrote a free OTGW plugin for HomeSeer HS4, based on the realtime (PS=0) messages. It just got released by HS. The plugin supports as many MsgIDs as possible.

During development I came across a few MsgIDs that did not entirely make sense: 38, 78 and 107. The register data types are defined as u8/u8, while their description only has 1 value. In my code for now I have assumed MsgID38 and MsgID78 (humidity) are f8.8 and MsgID107HB is u8, comparable to MsgID12.

And then there is MsgID30, which is defined as both s16 and f8.8 in the old 2.2 protocol. i think f8.8 is a copy/paste error, as s16 matches the -40..250 range which is unique and therefore less likely a copy/paste error.

Do you possibly have more information on these MsgIDs? Maybe from uploaded logs on your website? (Or newer protocol documents?)

Best regards, Bernold

hvxl commented 1 year ago

You are correct that those MsgIDs should not be u8/u8. Your guesses of what they should be are mostly correct too. The exception is MsgID 78. That is nu/u8.

Information in the spec about MsgID 30 is indeed contradictory. But the range doesn't fit in any number format other than s16. So I agree that must be the correct format.

I will update otmonitor. Thanks.

BernoldNL commented 1 year ago

Thank you for your quick response and your information. I will update my plugin.