search

hyperboria / peers

A geographically sorted list of public peering credentials for joining Hyperboria
200 stars 74 forks source link

add removal policy #4

Open ansuz opened 9 years ago

ansuz commented 9 years ago

At what point are credentials considered expired?

dansup commented 9 years ago

I think we should give operators some response time (say 48 hours) to address credential issues, and if they do not respond to the issue that it should be removed.

On Sat, Oct 3, 2015, 2:53 PM ansuz notifications@github.com wrote:

At what point are credentials considered expired?

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/hyperboria/peers/issues/4.

ansuz commented 9 years ago

48 is probably a little short. It's a volunteer project and people will get annoyed if they go on vacation and their server goes down. A week?

oxzi commented 8 years ago

I just wanted to open a similar issue before I found this one. It seems like a lot of the offered peers (tested only EU) are no longer reachable and it's quite frustrating to try to connect to dead nodes. A simple UDP-portscan with nmap resulted in closed ports for:

Is there something planed which isn't written in this issue so far?

ansuz commented 8 years ago

we were planning on setting up some automated testing, but it hasn't happened yet.

@jaythespacehound, @oniichaNj, @fbrandstetter, maybe you folks can report on the status of your nodes?

oniichaNj commented 8 years ago

My node should be up and running just fine, I used it the other day without issues whatsoever.

jaythespacehound commented 8 years ago

It seems to go down every few hours for me with no errors in the log. Process just vanishes. I've just pulled the latest version let's see if it stays up longer. If not I'll eventually cave and systemd it I guess.

fbrandstetter commented 8 years ago

I've removed this server it seems like. I'll fastly grab another one and setup CJDNS there and edit the config, so please don't delete it so far. Feel free to mark it as "down" meanwhile though.

ansuz commented 7 years ago

We should probably remove public peers that aren't up to date (currently v18).

There are a number of fixes, and public peers should be a shining example for the rest of the network.