search

hyperledger / solang

Solidity Compiler for Solana and Polkadot
https://solang.readthedocs.io/
Apache License 2.0
1.22k stars 207 forks source link

Release 0.3.4 Athens #1639

Open xermicus opened 2 months ago

xermicus commented 2 months ago

This release brings various improvements and bug fixes to our stable compilation targets. Notably, the Polkadot target is now compatible with ink! version 5.0 metadata.

xermicus commented 1 month ago

Unfortunately cargo publish will fail, as we depend on forge-fmt which depends on solang-parser =0.3.2.

While pinned dependencies in libraries is definitely annoying; I think depending on our own crate via a third party would block us anyways, for example what if we wanted to release a major version?

seanyoung commented 1 month ago

Unfortunately cargo publish will fail, as we depend on forge-fmt which depends on solang-parser =0.3.2.

I think forge-fmt should copied into the solang repo. The published crate is not being updated.

While pinned dependencies in libraries is definitely annoying; I think depending on our own crate via a third party would block us anyways, for example what if we wanted to release a major version?

Yep, that's not good. Copying it into our repo would solve that problem, and we can make sure the formatter is up to date with the latest syntax too - right now, it's out of date and cannot parse everything that solang can.

xermicus commented 1 month ago

Right, given the licenses, both Apache 2.0, are compatible, I think this should work.

The other solution coming to my mind would be to factor the language server out into a dedicated project (I think just outside the solang worspace would do too)?

seanyoung commented 1 month ago

Right, given the licenses, both Apache 2.0, are compatible, I think this should work.

The other solution coming to my mind would be to factor the language server out into a dedicated project (I think just outside the solang worspace would do too)?

That doesn't solve the problem, as the language server would have the same issue.

On the up-side, the solang crate would not have any problems :)

I've had a quick stab at copying forge-fmt into the solang repo. It needs some work, most notably forge-fmt needs to updated to use the latest parse tree.

xermicus commented 1 month ago

That doesn't solve the problem, as the language server would have the same issue.

I see, so the solution would rather be factoring solang-parser out of the workspace I guess.

I've had a quick stab at copying forge-fmt into the solang repo. It needs some work, most notably forge-fmt needs to updated to use the latest parse tree.

Any idea why foundry themselves are not doing it? You are right, the last release of forge-fmt was 9 months back which is quite a while

seanyoung commented 1 month ago

Any idea why foundry themselves are not doing it? You are right, the last release of forge-fmt was 9 months back which is quite a while

From what I can see, foundry don't update their crates on crates.io - they published forge-fmt after I asked them.