search

i-adopt / ontology

Sources of the I-ADOPT ontology.
https://w3id.org/iadopt/
2 stars 2 forks source link

The relation between Observed Entity Role, ObjectOfInterest and Context Object #7

Closed kitchenprinzessin3880 closed 3 years ago

kitchenprinzessin3880 commented 3 years ago

@mabablue @gwemon @SirkoS @huberrob

I read the framework doc https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NGC5BQ9tKsGWnh_IFtMLBWu-BlT8vpulAanF6zYEr2I/edit# the relations between Observed Entity Role, ObjectOfInterest and Context Object is ambiguous. My suggestions are as follows:

OPTION 1

  1. There is one concept called ObservedEntity, which can 'playrole' as ObjectOfInterest and Context Object
  2. Property is a 'PropertyOf' ObservedEntity
  3. When an ObservedEntity assumes a role, it is 'constrainedBy' Constraint.

OPTION 2

  1. There is one concept called ObservedEntity, which can 'playrole' as ObjectOfInterest and Context Object
  2. Property is a 'PropertyOf' ObjectOfInterest
  3. When an ObservedEntity assumes a role, it is 'constrainedBy' Constraint.

any thoughts?

SirkoS commented 3 years ago

Can you maybe expand a little on the ambiguity you see in the structure, please?

From my current view, it's only a matter of getting the definitions right, but the structure overall seems fitting

gwemon commented 3 years ago

@kitchenprinzessin3880 please see @SirkoS 's question above. Is this still an open issue for you?

kitchenprinzessin3880 commented 3 years ago

@SirkoS @gwemon The issue seems like has been addressed by @mabablue here (page 4), https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NGC5BQ9tKsGWnh_IFtMLBWu-BlT8vpulAanF6zYEr2I/edit#heading=h.3ja7jtv0ix8r.