search

i40-Tools / OntEnrich

Application for knowledge graph enrichment through linking with DBpedia.
MIT License
1 stars 0 forks source link

Specifying sto:relatedTo property #3

Open mmaltsev opened 6 years ago

mmaltsev commented 6 years ago

Studying the property sto:relatedTo I found out that according to the resources where the relations themselve are described (wiki, dbpedia, official pages), relations can be of very different types. Below you can find the list of relation that were identified manualy:

sto:IEC_61499 isBasedOn sto:IEC_61131
sto:IEC_62264 isBasedOn sto:ISA-95
sto:W3C_OWL isBasedOn sto:W3C_RDF
sto:W3C_SPARQL isBasedOn sto:W3C_RDF

sto:IEC_61511 isSectorSpecificFor sto:IEC_61508 (sector - "process")
sto:IEC_62061 isSectorSpecificFor sto:IEC_61508 (sector - "manufacturing/machineries")

sto:IEC_61360 usesSameDatamodelAs sto:ISO_13584

sto:W3C_RIF isPartOf "the infrastructure for the semantic web"
sto:W3C_OWL isPartOf "the infrastructure for the semantic web"

In the STO, the property relatedTo is described as symmetric and transitive one but if we'll look at the identified relations, i.e. isBasedOn, we can see that this property is clearly not symmetric (sto:IEC_61499 isBasedOn sto:IEC_61131 is True but sto:IEC_61131 isBasedOn sto:IEC_61499 is False).

I believe that a more specific interpretation of the property sto:relatedTo can help us in constructing the landscape.

igrangel commented 6 years ago

Could you point out explicitly from where you derived the properties isBasedOn, isSectorSpecificFor, usesSameDataModelAs, and isPartOf?

mmaltsev commented 6 years ago

sto:IEC_61499 isBasedOn sto:IEC_61131 (second sentence from the top) sto:IEC_62264 isBasedOn sto:ISA-95 (second sentence from the top) sto:W3C_OWL isBasedOn sto:W3C_RDF (can't remember now, might be just general knowledge) sto:W3C_SPARQL isBasedOn sto:W3C_RDF (can't remember now, might be just general knowledge)

sto:IEC_61511 isSectorSpecificFor sto:IEC_61508 (sector - "process") (section Process industries) sto:IEC_62061 isSectorSpecificFor sto:IEC_61508 (sector - "manufacturing/machineries") (section Machinery)

sto:IEC_61360 usesSameDatamodelAs sto:ISO_13584 (last sentence of the article)

sto:W3C_RIF isPartOf "the infrastructure for the semantic web" (second sentence of the rdfs:comment object) sto:W3C_OWL isPartOf "the infrastructure for the semantic web" (second sentence of the rdfs:comment object)