search

i9yogurt / granary

0 stars 0 forks source link

Feedback for Ver0.3 #3

Open DavidZtako opened 3 years ago

DavidZtako commented 3 years ago

Hi i9yogurt,

I've tested your grasshopper component (Ver0.3), and there are some of my thinking and comments for it.

  1. I think what type of tool you want to generate may be one direction that can be considered to create your tool. It can be questions like what do you want to achieve by developing this tool? Or maybe what relationships/scenarios between kinds of landscape features do you want to explore further by using your tool?

  2. I can see you try to express the relationship between the different landscape elements using the grid tool (collage, coffee shop, bar, etc.) I would say this can dig further by more specific definitions or questions (E.g. what's the definition of 'around something' in your component? How large is it? Is there some intangible connection inside a landscape feature? Or maybe across several features? Looking at tags and reports of OSM landscape features listed by Caribou and finding what you are interested in / What landscape features do you use to generate your tool would be a starting point to consistently developing your tool.

  3. As you finish a component, write a short brief to introduce how the component can help other users understand your component's logic and how to operate it correctly with their own OSM file.

Keep going. Cheers!

David

i9yogurt commented 3 years ago

Hi David,

I'm glad you tested my component(Ver0.3) and asked some questions about it. Let me answer your doubts.

  1. Yes, I am thinking about creating my tools. I want to explore the traffic problems of the street landscape and the relationship between people's parking and activities. At this stage, I haven't put all the components together. I think I will rebuild a finished component later to help you test it.

  2. At first, I wanted to consider the relationship between the school and surrounding entertainment venues. As you said, this is not clear enough. So in the updated 0.4, I will reconsider my centre point, which is the parks of city streets. Then test the connection and range between 500m, 1000m and 1500m around the parks.

  3. Yes, I think you are right, I should organize a logical component, and I will update them later.

Regards, I9yogurt(Ming)