QOS for dividing download speed between more PC

[GoogleCodeExporter]

What steps will reproduce the problem?
I run Jdownloader on PC1 so QOS run very well (after downloading 512kB speed 
will drop to 100kB/s ; Rule 12-Class Low, see atchm. pictures) but at same time 
on PC2 I wanna download something small (few MB, such a Windows updates etc.) 
and there I got initial download speed only 20-30kB/s and which slowly 
decreasing and mostly this download ends with 0kB speed=timeout what´s mean 
stopping and broken file/download. 

What is the expected output?
Dividing of bandwidth.

What version of the product are you using? On what operating system?
Tomato Firmware v1.28.0020 Teaman-SDHC-VLAN ND USB VPN.trx

Original issue reported on code.google.com by mstefa...@gmail.com on 10 Feb 2012 at 11:28

Attachments:

• Qos2.jpg
• Qos1.jpg

[GoogleCodeExporter]

I guess Qos1.jpg was taken from qos-settings.asp and Qos2.jpg was taken from 
qos-classify.asp, right?

So... did you notice that above the list of rules on page qos-classify.asp it 
says... "Outbound Direction"?

Unfortunately, there's no such fine-granularity regarding QoS settings for 
"Incoming" traffic (at least, I'm not aware of anything like that). There /is/ 
some L7 matching/filtering available (but that's on the Advanced -> 
Conntrack/Netfilter page).

In any case: perhaps... you might have any extra/additional QoS scripts/rules 
being loaded by some custom script (i.e. saved on nvram/jffs/etc... ?)

Original comment by augu...@bott.com.br on 11 Feb 2012 at 1:00

• Changed state: PendingFeedback

[GoogleCodeExporter]

1, correct
2, yes, but I'm not talking about ¨Outgoing Direction  but about ¨Inbound¨
3, For me it´s interesting that when I tested another 
firm.(tomato-NDUSB-1.28.7632.3-... ver.) where download speed between PCs was 
divided with QOS very well [it´s possible to say that it was 50%(PC1) : 
50%(PC2) at the same time]. But there was problem with QOS jumps between the 
thresholds (such 60kB-120kB-90kB-42kB-180kB etc. = Jdownloader´s problem with 
correct time estimating; jumps between within 2-3hours, what wasn´t true ; see 
atch.). Another interesting thing I didn´t meet with this problem at you.
4, No, I don´t use QOS scripts which you mentioned

Original comment by mstefa...@gmail.com on 11 Feb 2012 at 7:50

Attachments:

• Difference.jpg

[GoogleCodeExporter]

This one is looking very hard to hunt/track down - specially since Teaman-ND 
has pretty much the same code for QoS as 'plain' Tomato - but this might be 
slightly different on Toastman-RT builds...

Still - something just occurred to me: on QoS/Basic Settings 
(qos-settings.asp), there's a special setting regarding the QoS Qdisc Scheduler 
(pfifo/sfq). I wonder if perhaps this particular thingie might be possibly 
related to what you've been experiencing?

Thanks,

Original comment by augu...@bott.com.br on 17 Feb 2012 at 10:20

[GoogleCodeExporter]

I tried it but no differences which could be to visible :)

Original comment by mstefa...@gmail.com on 23 Feb 2012 at 6:59

[GoogleCodeExporter]

And another one issue with QOS:

I created rules for L7-Httpvideo : 

A, Size less than 20MB(bigger download speed)
B, Size bigger(slow download speed)

But I´ve never come to rule B, I remain always on rule A. I tested this issue 
on another firm.-and wasn´t problem(but I wasn´t therewith happy as with 
yours :-)) )

Original comment by mstefa...@gmail.com on 7 Mar 2012 at 7:17

[GoogleCodeExporter]

Cannot verify/repeat/reproduce these problems. Please try a new/more recent 
version. Thanks.

Original comment by augu...@bott.com.br on 15 Jun 2012 at 7:15

• Changed state: WontFix