search

iLampard / hypro_tpp

PyTorch Implementation of Hybridly Normalized Probabilistic Model for Long-Horizon Prediction of Event Sequence, NeurIPS 2022
Apache License 2.0
4 stars 0 forks source link

Question about baselines #2

Closed ivan-chai closed 1 month ago

ivan-chai commented 1 month ago

Dear authors of the HYPRO,

Thank you for publishing the paper and sharing the official implementation of the method!

I try to understand the experimental setup and come to the following questions:

  1. How can I reproduce the results for baseline methods (NHP, DualTPP, etc.)?
  2. Did you use sampling, expectation, or maximum likelihood prediction for the baselines?
  3. Did you compare the proposed rescoring method with a beam search?

Looking forward to your reply and would be very grateful for any clarifications.

iLampard commented 1 month ago

Hi Ivan

  1. How can I reproduce the results for baseline methods (NHP, DualTPP, etc.)?

For NHP, please use either EasyTPP or the code in AttNHP ( you need to deactivate the att block).

For DualTPP, we use the author's code.

  1. Did you use sampling, expectation, or maximum likelihood prediction for the baselines?

We use what the original code provides. For NHP it is maximum likelihood prediction. For DualTPP, i forgot, maybe not maximum likelihood prediction.

  1. Did you compare the proposed rescoring method with a beam search?

No.

Looking forward to your reply and would be very grateful for any clarifications.