iMicknl / ha-tahoma

Custom component for Home Assistant to interact with smart devices via Somfy TaHoma or other OverKiz based API's.
MIT License
151 stars 30 forks source link

Cannot use cover in Google Home #813

Closed atallo closed 2 years ago

atallo commented 2 years ago

Did you read the instructions?

The request

I have several Sonfy automatic covers. When I use them in HA using "https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/somfy" I can use them from Google Home. Instead when I add them to HA using "https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/overkiz" in Google Home they appear differently and I can't manage them from the app.

image

Which gateway / hub do you use?

conxion

Device model (optional)

No response

Device type (optional)

No response

Additional information

No response

tetienne commented 2 years ago

Hi, integrations are not responsible to what is exposed within Google Assistant, Alexa, and Home Kit. I guess there is something wrong in your Google Assistant configuration within HA. Please have a look to the documentation.

atallo commented 2 years ago

I don't think it's a problem with Google Home.

I've been doing more tests, I think this component could be improved (a little more) but you can close this issue.

Google Home needs the device to be of type "cover" and this component creates it as "shutter", whereas the old integration did it as "cover" and that's why it worked correctly.

I just changed the type manually, and now Google Home detects it correctly.

Thank you and sorry.

tetienne commented 2 years ago

You can see the device classes description here. We tried to respect it as much as possible.

atallo commented 2 years ago

I add a couple of screenshots so you can see the difference.a.

Using this integrantion: image

Using old integration (work in Google Home)

image

Change type in HA, using this integration (work in Google Home)

image

tetienne commented 2 years ago

To be honest within the Somfy integration, I didn’t be really accurate within the device class. Somfy didn’t send anything special to distinct the type of cover. But it’s the case here.

Can you please attach here the diagnotic information related to your device if you are using the "offial" overkiz component or the debug log if you are still using this custom component (not recommanded anymore if you have only cover)?

atallo commented 2 years ago

This file? https://www.dropbox.com/s/kdvs2dlff3z01wk/overkiz-9bdb197c7911844d0f5a5250bd5e5e43-Connexoon-0e63569c86be1a3ba529720ddbd5e413.json.txt?dl=0

Is this product: https://www.somfy.es/productos/persianas-y-estores-motorizados/persianas-motorizadas Working video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Gp6lgSkzWs (tipical used in Spain)