search

iNavFlight / blackbox-log-viewer

Interactive log viewer for flight logs recorded with blackbox
GNU General Public License v3.0
35 stars 22 forks source link

Frequency axis on Analyzer view shows infinite frequency #91

Closed aviphysics closed 2 months ago

aviphysics commented 10 months ago

The frequency axis in the analyzer view shows infinite frequency. I am using the latest release version of iNav7 and the Blackbox log viewer available at the time of posting. The data from iNav appears valid and I can do the FFT and plot in Octave, so this seems to be a problem with the blackbox log viewer.

image

Phil-MC commented 10 months ago

I've seen a couple of comments on the forums with users asking what the frequencies are. The axis label seems to have taken over from the scale labels in the display. I can't find the word infinite in the code. @DzikuVx

aviphysics commented 10 months ago

I've seen a couple of comments on the forums with users asking what the frequencies are. The axis label seems to have taken over from the scale labels in the display. I can't find the word infinite in the code. @DzikuVx

Did you try looking for "infinity"?

Edit: NVM that doesn't come up either.

Phil-MC commented 10 months ago

I did look for infinity as well using github search and there were no hits in the code. I hope @DzikuVx has a look at this problem. I can see lots of users having problems with it. The graphs look OK, it's just the labelling.

rts18 commented 9 months ago

@spatzengr If you find some time. Can you please take a look at this issue. Possibly caused by #86

spatzengr commented 9 months ago

@rts18 , yes. I noticed the same issue but didn't associate it with #86 , but I can investigate to see wsup.

balbusky21 commented 8 months ago

I'm having the same issue. Is there a fix yet for this? I'm having issues tunning my filters. or is there a work around?

aviphysics commented 8 months ago

I'm having the same issue. Is there a fix yet for this? I'm having issues tunning my filters. or is there a work around?

My current work around is to use the last version of BBV

Phil-MC commented 8 months ago

I gather it can be caused by missing entries in the BB Recording. Try reducing the amount of data collected. Some of the FC's are at the limit of what their design can handle.

aviphysics commented 8 months ago

I gather it can be caused by missing entries in the BB Recording. Try reducing the amount of data collected. Some of the FC's are at the limit of what their design can handle.

I don't think that is the problem here (or not the entire problem)

For one thing, BBV5 can render the FFT with scale without a problem from the same dataset that doesn't work in BBV7.

Have you been able to demonstrate a working FFT scale in BBV7?

Phil-MC commented 8 months ago

You need to verify that the log has no missing entries. There is an excellent set of BlackBox Tools written by Jonathan Hudson on Github, which can verify this. He can be contacted on our Discord Forum as @stronnag .

aviphysics commented 8 months ago

You need to verify that the log has no missing entries. There is an excellent set of BlackBox Tools written by Jonathan Hudson on Github, which can verify this. He can be contacted on our Discord Forum as @stronnag .

Can you demonstrate that BBV7 works with any logs? Why does the BBV5 work with the logs and BBV7 doesn't?

BTW, I had already tried on multiple quads and log rates. One of the quads I switched to BF, and it didn't seem to have any log issues (BF BBV worked correctly.) Also, one of the FC was using SD card for logs and the other was using a 16MB flash chip.

Phil-MC commented 8 months ago

I think BBv5 is probably less fussy and skips over problems. BBv7 might be doing something new. Ask @stronnag on Discord. Sent from my Galaxy

aviphysics commented 7 months ago

I think BBv5 is probably less fussy and skips over problems. BBv7 might be doing something new. Ask @stronnag on Discord. Sent from my Galaxy

Do you have any to examples of a successful frequency plot?

Phil-MC commented 7 months ago

BB1 BB2

These were produced more than a year ago and show vibration before and after replacing a problem motor.

Unfortunately I did not record the version of BB explorer I used but it was 2023/24. It wasn't the current one!

Phil-MC commented 7 months ago

What FC generated the BB recording, which caused the problem?

rts18 commented 7 months ago

I don't think that is the problem here (or not the entire problem) For one thing, BBV5 can render the FFT with scale without a problem from the same dataset that doesn't work in BBV7.

@aviphysics I can confirm your findings. I see infinity on every copter or plane log I record, when viewed with blackbox explorer 7. However all logs render the FFT scale consistently with BBE 5.

mmosca commented 2 months ago

7.0.1 should fix this.

Phil-MC commented 2 months ago

Presumably, you refer to the firmware and not the CONFIGURATOR. Does this extend up the line to 7.1.1 and the latest 7.1.2 ?

mmosca commented 2 months ago

7.0.1 of blackbox log viewer.

Phil-MC commented 2 months ago

Thanks, I should have thought of that....