search

iNavFlight / inav

INAV: Navigation-enabled flight control software
https://inavflight.github.io
GNU General Public License v3.0
3.12k stars 1.47k forks source link

MSP2 over Crsf Telemety for PID lua Script like betaflight #9524

Closed druckgott closed 6 months ago

druckgott commented 10 months ago

Current Behavior

MSP2 is currently not Supported over CRSF Telemetry so we cant use lua script to change pids with transmitter

Desired Behavior

MSP2 is supported over CRSF Telemetry so that we can use a first script and implement more and more things like on betaflight lua script

Suggested Solution

It would be cool to have a Script like in betaflight to send PIDS and so on with LUA to change it on the Transmitter and do not need a App ore PC or anything else.

klutvott123 have thxfully implementet mps2 for the lua script https://github.com/betaflight/betaflight-tx-lua-scripts/issues/491

I have done a version which already starts with inav but only gets msp1 values which is currently not very usefull for PIDS. https://github.com/druckgott/betaflight-tx-lua-scripts/tree/inav_version I will later make a fork from betaflight script and change again all so that the commit history from betaflight is also availibe.

Who does this impact? Who is this for?

Everybody who will use a lua script on Transmitter to change PIds without extra tool and not with any switches in INV which maybe not availble due to other functions

Additional context

Would be realy cool if we can do this and then extend the lua script lick the betaflight lua script

druckgott commented 10 months ago

Did Start here no Compile error alrady, but Lua Script says Waiting for API and I do not know how to debug both (lua and inav itself) https://github.com/iNavFlight/inav/pull/9528

maxledfreak commented 10 months ago

Hello @druckgott,

this feature sounds intriguing! While setting up via mobile phone has been a common approach in the past, it's not always the ideal solution. I've come across information suggesting that configuring it through switches and their connections might be a more efficient method. I will try this.

Moreover, there's a LUA script available for iNav in general. Integrating it into this script could potentially enhance the setup process. From a usability standpoint, configuring it through a LUA script seems to be a superior option compared to using a mobile phone.

Have you had a successful run with your first PR?

@DzikuVx, could we consider adding this feature to the roadmap for upcomming iNav versions?

MrD-RC commented 10 months ago

Honestly, I find the adjustments so much more convenient. You can do it in flight. No need to land, remove your goggles, and look at your radio.

druckgott commented 10 months ago

It depends how you want to do it. For me in flight is not realy nice, I have do use so much buttons have to concentrate maybe something goes wrong and the wing is crashing which makes no sence for me. I want to land switch the value start again, get new log file ... and this is happening automaticaly if I use this script. I think this is depending on the people how they want to do it. Maybe for you it´s not nice but I think there are other people who find it nice. Maybe lets focus on adding good tings to inav ;-). I don´t want to discuss the preferences from people ;-).

I´m not a fan to have many swiches for on the rx to do maybe wrong things due to the many swiches. And there is a clear menü in lua script and I clearly know what I´m doing.

RomanLut commented 10 months ago

No so excited about tuning pids with lua script on my Jumper T-Lite screen :smiley:, but this feature would make wireless configurator communication possible https://github.com/iNavFlight/inav-configurator/issues/1616