How do I support solidjs? Can you implement a slate-solid？

ianstormtaylor / slate

A completely customizable framework for building rich text editors. (Currently in beta.)

http://slatejs.org

MIT License

29.87k stars 3.24k forks source link

How do I support solidjs? Can you implement a slate-solid？ #5588

Open solid-component opened 9 months ago

solid-component commented 9 months ago

I want to write an editor in solidjs and slate, but slate only has a Slate-React component, can I write a Slate-solid component based on Slate-React?

adjourn commented 9 months ago

Not really, JSX is where the similarities end..

Rendering paradigms couldn't be more different
Solid doesn't have synthetic event system on top of native events

You could probably build it on top of slate-react to reuse some of the code but be prepared to rewrite all the components and everything to do with events but.. I'm afraid this is the layer where bulk of the WYSIWYG editor difficulties and bugs are, I would not recommend it as a solo project.

dylans commented 8 months ago

There's slate-angular as an example of a non-React version of Slate. There's also slate-vue though it is not maintained as far as I can tell.

I wouldn't be opposed to introducing a slate-solid (or other variants) to slate itself, but we really need to add a good test suite for slate-react and anything new.

Noobulater commented 3 months ago

I'd contribute to a bounty to get this library working for solidjs. Built out a tech stack for preact using it, but have recently migrated to solidjs

bmingles commented 2 months ago

Have you seen at this repo? https://github.com/poudels14/slate-solid

Haven’t tested but looks like someone has at least started this idea.

Noobulater commented 2 months ago

Have you seen at this repo? https://github.com/poudels14/slate-solid

Haven’t tested but looks like someone has at least started this idea.

Yeah, unfortunately the repo broke somewhere along the development of solid, been a while so I don't remember which version exactly. Tried to pay a freelancer to clean it up, but their attempt was wildly unsuccessful, and I'm just wanting to throw money at the conversion rather than learn or attempt it myself.

bmingles commented 1 month ago

@Noobulater if you ever decide to issue a bounty I’d be interested in a link to the details.

Noobulater commented 1 month ago

@Noobulater if you ever decide to issue a bounty I’d be interested in a link to the details.

@bmingles If this had a functional equivalent in solid for the following, I'd easily be willing to drop $ usd on it. If that sounds reasonable we can discuss the requirements in a more formal way.

bmingles commented 1 month ago

@Noobulater I'd be interested in talking about this more formally. My linkedin profile should be visible on my github profile if you want to connect with me there, or let me know how I can contact you elsewhere.