search

ibi-group / trimet-mod-otp

5 stars 5 forks source link

gtfsdb does not associate routes with stops that have drop off only stoptimes #217

Open landonreed opened 5 years ago

landonreed commented 5 years ago

This stop should have route 24 showing up in this TI call: https://modbeta.trimet.org/ws/ti/v0/index/stops/TriMet:14036/routes. It's showing up in the Transit Tracker as expected: https://trimet.org/#tracker/stop/14036

@msrichardson identified that this stop is "alighting only" and provided some other examples from TriMet's GTFS:

Here are a couple more alighting only stops: 13247 and 9545. ID 1273 is alighting only only for Line 8 (full service for Line 75). There are more of both types, and similarly, we also have boarding only stops (ID 13248 is an example).

msrichardson commented 5 years ago

There also appears to be an issue with stops that are served by both revenue service buses and non-revenue service buses (that is, at minimum stop is served by one route that is board/alight and one that is non-board/non-alight at the stop. See https://github.com/opentripplanner/otp-react-redux/pull/93 (this is likely the issue for ID 715, which has this situation as of mid-July of this year - Line 20 is board/alight, while lines 36 and 94 are not)