search

icebob / microservices-benchmark

Benchmark of microservices frameworks for NodeJS
40 stars 12 forks source link

Fair comparison #2

Closed StarpTech closed 7 years ago

StarpTech commented 7 years ago

Hi, great to see a benchmark about microservice frameworks in NodeJs. I'm the creator of hemera and would like to tell you my opinion about this test. Hemera is using a message bus called NATS which implicit extra roundtrips.

Requestor->Server->Responder->Server->Requestor

This falsified the current benchmark because all request / response from Seneca, Moleculer, Nanoservices are processed in-memory. I propose a test with multiple microservices on different processes or hosts. Even this environment would be wrong to compare because hemera falls under a different category as long as the other frameworks dont use NATS / Broker as transport. If you compare your benchmark of NATS as transport we can get very similiar results.

Thank you

icebob commented 7 years ago

Hi @StarpTech! Thanks for you inquiry. Yes it's true. I will create an other test suite where every frameworks will do a "remote" request via a broker/transporter. I don't know Seneca is supported NATS.

StarpTech commented 7 years ago

@icebob seems so https://github.com/cmfatih/seneca-nats-transport but not official.

icebob commented 7 years ago

Thanks. I will try it

icebob commented 7 years ago

@StarpTech I created a remote test suite & updated readme with the results.

StarpTech commented 7 years ago

@icebob great, thanks for the update.