ices-tools-dev / RDBES

The public repository of the RDBES development.
11 stars 5 forks source link

CL and CE, Statistical rectangle - data source #132

Open josefineegekvist opened 3 years ago

josefineegekvist commented 3 years ago

In relation to the small-scale fisheries, the ICES rectangle is often not reported in logbooks, but is derived or estimated from other data sources. The WGCATCH subgroup B suggests to add an extra field called ‘Statistical Rectangle Source’ with the options to enter ‘Logbook’, ‘Based on harbor location’, ‘Based on positional data’, ‘Other data sources’.

josefineegekvist commented 2 years ago

After meeting with Sébastien Demaneche, it was still found useful to add the “Statistical Rectangle Source” field as a quality indicator for the spatial information in the CE and CL data, as is one for the value of landings, and especially for the small-scale fishery where the ICES rectangles are often estimated, it would be good to know the source. This doesn't apply to other fields.

josefineegekvist commented 2 years ago

Discussed 11/01/2022 by RDBES CE CL subgroup Agree to add the field.

HenrikK-N commented 2 years ago

The Core Group agree to add the field “Statistical Rectangle Source”. The CL CE subgroup and more persons will help specify codes and examples for the full records of the CL and CE.

josefineegekvist commented 2 years ago

Discussed at CL CE meeting 03/03/2022. Following codes and descriptions are suggested:

RepLogbook - Statistical rectangle reported in logbook AdjPosData - Adjusted based on positional data EstHarbLoc - Estimated based on harbour location EstPosData - Estimated based on positional data EstExpKnow - Estimated based on expert knowledge EstOther - Estimated based on other data sources