ichthyop / ichthyop

A Lagrangian tool for simulating ichthyoplankton dynamics
http://www.ichthyop.org/
GNU General Public License v3.0
5 stars 7 forks source link

Coastline behaviour: Standstill vs Beaching #97

Open ytmben opened 3 months ago

ytmben commented 3 months ago

Hello,

This might be a bit of a silly question, but I have been noticing that running a simulation with the coastline behavior set to Beaching outputs very different results to that same simulation but with a coastline behavior set to Standstill. Is this because the particles interfere with each other once they are assumed beached? Or because of difference in movement with the circulation when the particle density is smaller? Or something else? This is mainly a question to understand how Ichthyop calculates this, so I can better plan my future simulations.

Thank you, Yotam

barriern commented 3 months ago

Hi Yotam.

When the particle is moved, it is falls inland:

This might explain the different behaviors

Nicolas

ytmben commented 3 months ago

Hi Nicolas, thank you for the quick reply,

So with standstill, the particles return to the immediate previous position they were before they fell inland? Or to the original position of the simulation? As for the post-processing, I already remove the dead particles when plotting them, I will see if I manage to do the same when creating the density plots, thank you.

Thanks again, Yotam

barriern commented 3 months ago

Its the position before it fell inland, not the original position

ytmben commented 3 months ago

Thank you! Would you mind if I keep this issue open, in case I have any more questions about the subject later on?

barriern commented 2 months ago

Sure, you can leave the issue opened