icub-tech-iit / documentation

iCub Tech Docs
https://icub-tech-iit.github.io/documentation/
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
24 stars 34 forks source link

Unable to find some datasheet of the geaboxes mounted on ergoCubV1_* #359

Closed GiulioRomualdi closed 1 week ago

GiulioRomualdi commented 2 months ago

Hi, I was looking for the datasheets of the gearboxes mounted on the ergoCubV1_* model. I found them on this webpage.

I tried to look at the datasheet of the gearboxes online but had some problems finding the datasheet for some joints. Here is a table with the datasheets I found

Joint Geabox of the documentation Datasheet
Joint 0 - shoulder pitch CSD-20-100-2UH 🟢 here
Joint 1 - shoulder roll CSD-17-100-2A 🟠 I assume is this one even if this model I linked is the CSD-17-100-2A-R while the one in the documentation is CSD-17-100-2A
Joint 2 - shoulder yaw CSD-17-100-2UH 🟢 here
Joint 3 - elbow CSD-17-100-2A 🟠 I assume is this one even if this model I linked is the CSD-17-100-2A-R while the one in the documentation is CSD-17-100-2A
Joint 0 - torso roll CSD-20-100-2UH 🟢 here
Joint 1 - torso pitch CSD-20-160-2UH 🔴 This gearbox does not seem to exist these are the gearboxes of the family CSD-2UH
Joint 2 - torso yaw CSD-20-100-2UH 🟢 here
Joint 0 - hip pitch CSD-25-100-2UH 🟢 here
Joint 1 - hip roll CSD-20-160-2UH 🔴 This gearbox does not seem to exist these are the gearboxes of the family CSD-2HU
Joint 2 - hip yaw CSD-20-100-2UH 🟢 here
Joint 3 - knee CSD-25-100-2UH 🟢 here
Joint 4 - ankle pitch CSD-25-100-2UH 🟢 here
Joint 5 - ankle roll CSD-17-160-2A 🔴 This gearbox does not seem to exist these are the gearboxes of the family CSD-2A

Could you help me in finding the missing part? I opened the issue here since there might be a problem with the documentation. Linking the datasheets in the documentation could also be beneficial.

cc @pattacini and @traversaro

traversaro commented 2 months ago

Probably also @fiorisi may know something about this.

GiulioRomualdi commented 2 months ago

With @fabiobergonti we checked the cad and the hip roll torso gearboxes are the one in the table and the info can be found here

image

On the other hand for CSD-17-160-2A we found this datasheet https://harmonicdrive.de/fileadmin/Downloads/Getriebe_Katalog/Harmonic_Drive_Gears_EN_1053522.pdf and as it can be seen in the picture the gearbox is not available image

GiulioRomualdi commented 2 months ago

We also checked the elbow and the shoulder roll CSD-17-100-2A similar to https://github.com/icub-tech-iit/documentation/issues/359#issuecomment-2343262188 the datasheet is here https://harmonicdrive.de/fileadmin/Downloads/Getriebe_Katalog/Harmonic_Drive_Gears_EN_1053522.pdf

image

So in the end the main problem is related to CSD-17-160-2A which does not exist in the datasheet

FabioBergonti commented 2 months ago

We tried to look for the cad of CSD-17-160-2A in https://harmonicdrive.partcommunity.com/3d-cad-models/csd-2a-harmonic-drive-gear-component-sets-harmonic-drive?info=harmonicdrive%2Fgetriebe_einbausaetze%2Fcsd_2a_asmtab.prj&cwid=6555 but it's not available image

GiulioRomualdi commented 2 months ago

with @fabiobergonti we went to the warehouse and we found the harmonic driver. The documentation is correct. The piece exists. 20240911_142000 (1)

maggia80 commented 2 months ago

if you want to have the datasheet, you can contact:

Crisafi Domenico

he should be still the contact person for Harmonic Drive.

fiorisi commented 2 months ago

@GiulioRomualdi I'll write a complete explanation, even if I have seen that you already found some answers.

The website that you are referring to, namely harmonicdrive.net, belongs to the US group Harmonic Drive LLC. For our geographical location we refer instead to Harmonic Drive SE (Germany), which has a different website harmonicdrive.de and sligthly different products.

For example, if I am not mistaken, the product CSD-20-160-2UH can be found on the German catalogue (see page 163).

image

Can you double check with the German catalogue if there are still differences?

Concerning the series 2A, I think that we didn't include -R because this suffix changes depending on the size of the HD (decision probably taken decades ago).

Finally, for the the part CSD-17-160-2A, this is a special harmonic drive that can not be found on the catalogue.

image

GiulioRomualdi commented 2 months ago

Thank you! So as far as I understood CSD-17-160-2A has been built ad hoc for us.

pattacini commented 1 week ago

We can close this issue, but I'm available to review PRs to improve the documentation.