idea-statica / iom-examples

Examples of using IDEA StatiCa IOM API
MIT License
8 stars 4 forks source link

[BUG] Cuts are wrong in BeamData #42

Closed jorgebslu closed 3 years ago

jorgebslu commented 4 years ago

Export the attached iom99.zip iom to Idea Connection.

Cuts applied on Stiffening member 1 are wrong unless I am not understanding correctly how to apply cuts. This is the connection I am exporting to Idea Connection:

image

And in Idea Connection I get:

What is not clear for me is the way that a cut plane is applied. I mean, what is the part of the object that is removed by the plane? The one on the side of the normal vector, or the opposite side of the normal vector? For example, in the following example, if I apply a cut plane to the yellow BeamData, what is the expected result, A or B? I would expect A, that is, the removed portion is the one on the normal vector side. image

Best regards

vojtech-chalupa commented 3 years ago

Hello, this bug concerns cutting of stiffening members by workplanes. An improved method of cutting stiffening members will resolve this and is planned for the version 21 release.

mpospisil commented 3 years ago

fixed in version 21.0.0.2340

https://jurajsabatkaideastatica-my.sharepoint.com/:f:/g/personal/martin_pospisil_ideastatica_com/EnyVy8RZmedPghx0FcCwoP4BtmJpUuP0x9OTbpRiWP9o0A?e=fb3etS

image