Some Group objects show as having approved charters which never did

[ietf-svn-bot]

owner:olau@iola.dk resolution_fixed type_defect | by rjsparks@nostrum.com

---

As part of a past migration of the data, several groups ended up with charter Document objects, that never had charters, much less approved ones.

This is leaving broken pages and misleading history in places like https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/charter-ietf-dmm-proposed/ and https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/charter-ietf-e2md/

Some of these are BoFs, and this data might have been created before we had the notion of concluded BoF in the data.

---

Issue migrated from trac:1292 at 2022-03-04 03:35:26 +0000

[ietf-svn-bot]

@rjsparks@nostrum.com changed owner from olau@iola.dk to ``

[ietf-svn-bot]

@rjsparks@nostrum.com commented

---

Need to tweak the autoassignment of tickets. It may be that Ole's the right person to tackle this, but auto-assigning it was not my intent.

[ietf-svn-bot]

@olau@iola.dk changed owner from ` toolau@iola.dk`

[ietf-svn-bot]

@olau@iola.dk commented

---

I had a look at this. I checked the list of charters here

http://www.ietf.org/charter/

http://www.ietf.org/wg-descriptions/

and checked my local database for groups with an approved charter but no actual file, and end up with the following list for review (acronym followed by group state):

aeiou      Concluded
cmot       Concluded
colip      Concluded
compen     Concluded
dlsw       Concluded
ddniwg     Concluded
opmeas     Concluded
roamreq    Concluded
dis        Concluded
dnsfutur   Concluded
dns2       Concluded
dcnl       Concluded
eid        Concluded
opera      Concluded
earthen    Concluded
guts       Concluded
peering    Concluded
hops       Concluded
hostreq    Concluded
httpsec    Concluded
httpmib    Concluded
ietfgrow   Concluded
emailmgt   Concluded
check      Concluded
isfoo      Concluded
imm        Concluded
ioh        Concluded
ima        Concluded
isoc       Concluded
ipaddr     Concluded
ipacad     Concluded
ngdir      Concluded
ngreqs     Concluded
nbmav6     Concluded
jomann     Concluded
wg-msg     Concluded
atmmib     Concluded
mboneng    Concluded
mbone      Concluded
msp        Concluded
pgpmime    Concluded
mplxmib    Concluded
rtqos      Concluded
x3s3.3     Concluded
nmarea     Concluded
nttcp      Concluded
nosi       Concluded
tcpng      Concluded
onc        Concluded
otsv       Concluded
orad       Concluded
ositrans   Concluded
nsfnet     Concluded
piara      Concluded
prottest   Concluded
realtime   Concluded
raidmib    Concluded
resdisc    Concluded
rfc1006    Concluded
rreqlist   Concluded
tspatm     Concluded
select     Concluded
ssl        Concluded
skip       Concluded
smpframe   Concluded
smibof     Concluded
snapper    Concluded
snamib     Concluded
snmpagen   Concluded
sam        Concluded
devdisc    Concluded
snmpxns    Concluded
snmpseci   Concluded
mibcomp    Concluded
tmux       Concluded
tcpfix     Concluded
tracerte   Concluded
trafchar   Concluded
tacit      Concluded
tadmin     Concluded
tsess      Concluded
txwg       Concluded
tcoord     Concluded
atminfo    Concluded
dmsp       Concluded
offpath    Concluded
ternli     Concluded
rtpsec     Concluded
wae        Concluded
sava       Concluded
spkm       Concluded
ifare      Concluded
fsm        Concluded
apm        Concluded
nee        Concluded
xsdmi      Concluded
tam        BOF Concluded
biff       Concluded
safe       Concluded
rl2n       Concluded
ippmxx     Concluded
rydeirde   Concluded
dmm-proposed Concluded

[ietf-svn-bot]

@olau@iola.dk commented

---

Side note: there's a problem here that some concluded WGs don't have a charter in the new format, probably because we just migrated the active groups, e.g.

http://datatracker.ietf.org/wg/vgmib/charter/ <- works

http://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/charter-ietf-vgmib/ <- doesn't work

I guess that could be fixed by copying the files over?

[ietf-svn-bot]

@rjsparks@nostrum.com commented

---

That list isn't quite right yet. A couple of datapoints: E2MD is not in the list - it is a concluded BoF You list rtpsec as concluded, but it is a concluded BoF

For situations like what you point to with vgmib, creating a charter document by copying those bits seems right.

[ietf-svn-bot]

@olau@iola.dk commented

---

Here's an updated list where very small charter files are not included. I had to check some manually. Note that this time, I didn't filter on type="wg" so some other group types with charters show up:

apparea      Active       AG
apptsv       Concluded    AG
genarea      Active       AG
opsarea      Active       AG
raiarea      Active       AG
rtgarea      Active       AG
saag         Active       AG
tsvarea      Active       AG
usvarea      Concluded    AG
iab          Active       IETF
iesg         Active       IETF
none         Active       Individual
cfrg         Active       RG
proto        Active       Team
secdir       Concluded    Team
tools        Active       Team
tsvdir       Concluded    Team
usac         Concluded    Team
6bonebof     Concluded    WG
abby         Concluded    WG
aeiou        Concluded    WG
afic         Concluded    WG
apm          Concluded    WG
atminfo      Concluded    WG
atmmib       Concluded    WG
biff         Concluded    WG
callhome     Concluded    WG
canmod       Concluded    WG
ceot         Concluded    WG
check        Concluded    WG
cidr         Concluded    WG
cmot         Concluded    WG
cnhhttp      Concluded    WG
colip        Concluded    WG
compen       Concluded    WG
dawg         Concluded    WG
dcnl         Concluded    WG
ddniwg       Concluded    WG
devdisc      Concluded    WG
dis          Concluded    WG
dlsw         Concluded    WG
dmm-proposed Concluded    WG
dmsp         Concluded    WG
dns2         Concluded    WG
dnsbof       Concluded    WG
dnsfutur     Concluded    WG
e2md         Concluded    WG
earthen      Concluded    WG
eid          Concluded    WG
emailmgt     Concluded    WG
esds         Concluded    WG
fedauth      Concluded    WG
fsm          Concluded    WG
ftpftam      Concluded    WG
gopher       Concluded    WG
guts         Concluded    WG
hasmat       Concluded    WG
hiccup       Concluded    WG
hipbof       Concluded    WG
hippi        Concluded    WG
hoakey       Concluded    WG
hops         Concluded    WG
hostreq      Concluded    WG
httpmib      Concluded    WG
httpsec      Concluded    WG
iddtspec     Concluded    WG
ieps         Concluded    WG
ietfgrow     Concluded    WG
ifare        Concluded    WG
iia          Concluded    WG
ima          Concluded    WG
imm          Concluded    WG
inaparch     Concluded    WG
intareawg    Concluded    WG
intprop      Concluded    WG
ioh          Concluded    WG
ipacad       Concluded    WG
ipaddr       Concluded    WG
ipnni        Concluded    WG
ippmxx       Concluded    WG
isfoo        Concluded    WG
isn2         Concluded    WG
isoc         Concluded    WG
iwg          Concluded    WG
jomann       Concluded    WG
kwns         Concluded    WG
lamug        Concluded    WG
letic        Concluded    WG
liaison      Concluded    WG
livdoc       Concluded    WG
loip         Concluded    WG
lowpan       Concluded    WG
lsd-old      Concluded    WG
lsthdr       Concluded    WG
lwip         Concluded    WG
mailreq      Concluded    WG
mbone        Concluded    WG
mboneng      Concluded    WG
mib          Concluded    WG
mibcomp      Concluded    WG
mimecont     Concluded    WG
mimereg      Concluded    WG
mmnet        Concluded    WG
mplxmib      Concluded    WG
msp          Concluded    WG
napmime      Concluded    WG
nbmav6       Concluded    WG
nbs          Concluded    WG
nee          Concluded    WG
netext2      Concluded    WG
netgraph     Concluded    WG
newgen       Concluded    WG
newprep      Concluded    WG
ngdir        Concluded    WG
ngreqs       Concluded    WG
nmarea       Concluded    WG
nosi         Concluded    WG
nsfnet       Concluded    WG
nttcp        Concluded    WG
offpath      Concluded    WG
omarea       Concluded    WG
onc          Concluded    WG
opera        Concluded    WG
opmeas       Concluded    WG
orad         Concluded    WG
ositrans     Concluded    WG
otsv         Concluded    WG
pages        Concluded    WG
peering      Concluded    WG
peppermint   Concluded    WG
pgpmime      Concluded    WG
piara        Concluded    WG
plasma       Concluded    WG
polterm      Concluded    WG
pre8prob     Concluded    WG
printjob     Concluded    WG
prottest     Concluded    WG
raidmib      Concluded    WG
rbridge      Concluded    WG
realtime     Concluded    WG
remmail      Concluded    WG
renum        Concluded    WG
resdisc      Concluded    WG
rfc1006      Concluded    WG
rl2n         Concluded    WG
road         Concluded    WG
roamreq      Concluded    WG
rreqlist     Concluded    WG
rtgtbl       Concluded    WG
rtl          Concluded    WG
rtpsec       Concluded    WG
rtqos        Concluded    WG
rucus        Concluded    WG
rydeirde     Concluded    WG
saad         Concluded    WG
safe         Concluded    WG
sam          Concluded    WG
sava         Concluded    WG
sbsm         Concluded    WG
scap         Concluded    WG
select       Concluded    WG
sip-o        Concluded    WG
skip         Concluded    WG
slrrp        Concluded    WG
smibof       Concluded    WG
smpframe     Concluded    WG
snamib       Concluded    WG
snapper      Concluded    WG
snmpagen     Concluded    WG
snmpseci     Concluded    WG
snmpxns      Concluded    WG
sofa         Concluded    WG
spkm         Concluded    WG
srp          Concluded    WG
ssl          Concluded    WG
stif         Concluded    WG
tacit        Concluded    WG
tadmin       Concluded    WG
tam          BOF Concluded WG
tana         Concluded    WG
tcoord       Concluded    WG
tcpfix       Concluded    WG
tcpng        Concluded    WG
telarch      Concluded    WG
teleconf     Concluded    WG
telnetlm     Concluded    WG
ternli       Concluded    WG
testing      Concluded    WG
tf           Concluded    WG
tmux         Concluded    WG
tracerte     Concluded    WG
trafchar     Concluded    WG
tsess        Concluded    WG
tspatm       Concluded    WG
ttcp         Concluded    WG
txwg         Concluded    WG
udi          Concluded    WG
uribof       Concluded    WG
urirev04     Concluded    WG
url          Concluded    WG
urp          Concluded    WG
vac          Concluded    WG
wae          Concluded    WG
wais         Concluded    WG
wg-char      Concluded    WG
wg-isus      Concluded    WG
wg-llt       Concluded    WG
wg-msg       Concluded    WG
wg-nap       Concluded    WG
wg-nop       Concluded    WG
wg-sec       Concluded    WG
wg1          Concluded    WG
wg2          Concluded    WG
wg4          Concluded    WG
wg5          Concluded    WG
wg8          Concluded    WG
wgdtspec     Concluded    WG
whois        Concluded    WG
www          Concluded    WG
x3s3.3       Concluded    WG
xmpp-old     Concluded    WG
xsdmi        Concluded    WG

[ietf-svn-bot]

@rjsparks@nostrum.com changed status from new to closed

[ietf-svn-bot]

@rjsparks@nostrum.com changed resolution from ` tofixed`

[ietf-svn-bot]

@rjsparks@nostrum.com commented

---

Patch 2014-04-04-fix_groups.py applied:

deleting charter-ietf-aeiou 01
deleting charter-ietf-apparea 01
deleting charter-ietf-apptsv 01
deleting charter-ietf-afic 01
deleting charter-ietf-cidr 01
deleting charter-ietf-cmot 01
deleting charter-ietf-colip 01
deleting charter-ietf-compen 01
deleting charter-ietf-dlsw 01
deleting charter-ietf-ddniwg 01
deleting charter-ietf-opmeas 01
deleting charter-ietf-roamreq 01
deleting charter-ietf-lamug 01
deleting charter-ietf-dis 01
deleting charter-ietf-dawg 01
deleting charter-ietf-dnsfutur 01
deleting charter-ietf-dns2 01
deleting charter-ietf-dnsbof 01
deleting charter-ietf-dcnl 01
deleting charter-ietf-mailreq 01
deleting charter-ietf-eid 01
deleting charter-ietf-opera 01
deleting charter-ietf-earthen 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg2 01
deleting charter-ietf-pages 01
deleting charter-ietf-ftpftam 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg5 01
deleting charter-ietf-gopher 01
deleting charter-ietf-guts 01
deleting charter-ietf-peering 01
deleting charter-ietf-hops 01
deleting charter-ietf-hostreq 01
deleting charter-ietf-httpsec 01
deleting charter-ietf-httpmib 01
deleting charter-ietf-ietfgrow 01
deleting charter-ietf-iesg 01
deleting charter-ietf-emailmgt 01
deleting charter-ietf-none 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg-isus 01
deleting charter-ietf-check 01
deleting charter-ietf-iia 01
deleting charter-ietf-ipnni 01
deleting charter-ietf-isfoo 01
deleting charter-ietf-intprop 01
deleting charter-ietf-imm 01
deleting charter-ietf-iwg 01
deleting charter-ietf-inaparch 01
deleting charter-ietf-ioh 01
deleting charter-ietf-iab 01
deleting charter-ietf-mib 01
deleting charter-ietf-ima 01
deleting charter-ietf-isn2 01
deleting charter-ietf-isoc 01
deleting charter-ietf-ipaddr 01
deleting charter-ietf-ipacad 01
deleting charter-ietf-hippi 01
deleting charter-ietf-ngdir 01
deleting charter-ietf-ngreqs 01
deleting charter-ietf-6bonebof 01
deleting charter-ietf-nbmav6 01
deleting charter-ietf-jomann 01
deleting charter-ietf-lsthdr 01
deleting charter-ietf-livdoc 01
deleting charter-ietf-loip 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg-llt 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg-msg 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg8 01
deleting charter-ietf-atmmib 01
deleting charter-ietf-mboneng 01
deleting charter-ietf-mbone 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg1 01
deleting charter-ietf-msp 01
deleting charter-ietf-mimecont 01
deleting charter-ietf-mimereg 01
deleting charter-ietf-pgpmime 01
deleting charter-ietf-mmnet 01
deleting charter-ietf-mplxmib 01
deleting charter-ietf-napmime 01
deleting charter-ietf-rtqos 01
deleting charter-ietf-abby 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg-nap 01
deleting charter-ietf-netgraph 01
deleting charter-ietf-x3s3.3 01
deleting charter-ietf-nmarea 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg-nop 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg4 01
deleting charter-ietf-nttcp 01
deleting charter-ietf-nosi 01
deleting charter-ietf-newgen 01
deleting charter-ietf-tcpng 01
deleting charter-ietf-onc 01
deleting charter-ietf-saag 01
deleting charter-ietf-otsv 01
deleting charter-ietf-orad 01
deleting charter-ietf-omarea 01
deleting charter-ietf-ositrans 01
deleting charter-ietf-nsfnet 01
deleting charter-ietf-piara 01
deleting charter-ietf-printjob 01
deleting charter-ietf-prottest 01
deleting charter-ietf-rtl 01
deleting charter-ietf-realtime 01
deleting charter-ietf-raidmib 01
deleting charter-ietf-remmail 01
deleting charter-ietf-resdisc 01
deleting charter-ietf-rfc1006 01
deleting charter-ietf-rreqlist 01
deleting charter-ietf-road 01
deleting charter-ietf-rtgtbl 01
deleting charter-ietf-tspatm 01
deleting charter-ietf-secdir 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg-sec 01
deleting charter-ietf-select 01
deleting charter-ietf-ssl 01
deleting charter-ietf-whois 01
deleting charter-ietf-sip-o 01
deleting charter-ietf-skip 01
deleting charter-ietf-smpframe 01
deleting charter-ietf-smibof 01
deleting charter-ietf-snapper 01
deleting charter-ietf-snamib 01
deleting charter-ietf-snmpagen 01
deleting charter-ietf-sam 01
deleting charter-ietf-devdisc 01
deleting charter-ietf-snmpxns 01
deleting charter-ietf-snmpseci 01
deleting charter-ietf-mibcomp 01
deleting charter-ietf-stif 01
deleting charter-ietf-sofa 01
deleting charter-ietf-tmux 01
deleting charter-ietf-tcpfix 01
deleting charter-ietf-teleconf 01
deleting charter-ietf-telarch 01
deleting charter-ietf-telnetlm 01
deleting charter-ietf-testing 01
deleting charter-ietf-tracerte 01
deleting charter-ietf-trafchar 01
deleting charter-ietf-ttcp 01
deleting charter-ietf-tacit 01
deleting charter-ietf-tsvdir 01
deleting charter-ietf-tadmin 01
deleting charter-ietf-tsess 01
deleting charter-ietf-txwg 01
deleting charter-ietf-tcoord 01
deleting charter-ietf-uribof 01
deleting charter-ietf-url 01
deleting charter-ietf-udi 01
deleting charter-ietf-usac 01
deleting charter-ietf-vac 01
deleting charter-ietf-wais 01
deleting charter-ietf-atminfo 01
deleting charter-ietf-wg-char 01
deleting charter-ietf-www 01
deleting charter-ietf-lsd-old 01
deleting charter-ietf-opsarea 01
deleting charter-ietf-rtgarea 01
deleting charter-ietf-usvarea 01
deleting charter-ietf-polterm 01
deleting charter-ietf-srp 01
deleting charter-ietf-ieps 01
deleting charter-ietf-cnhhttp 01
deleting charter-ietf-ceot 01
deleting charter-ietf-urp 01
deleting charter-ietf-kwns 01
deleting charter-ietf-xmpp-old 01
deleting charter-ietf-cfrg 01
deleting charter-ietf-saad 01
deleting charter-ietf-hipbof 01
deleting charter-ietf-sbsm 01
deleting charter-ietf-letic 01
deleting charter-ietf-genarea 01
deleting charter-ietf-rbridge 01
deleting charter-ietf-urirev04 01
deleting charter-ietf-lowpan 01
deleting charter-ietf-slrrp 01
deleting charter-ietf-liaison 01
deleting charter-ietf-tsvarea 01
deleting charter-ietf-callhome 01
deleting charter-ietf-raiarea 01
deleting charter-ietf-hoakey 01
deleting charter-ietf-dmsp 01
deleting charter-ietf-offpath 01
deleting charter-ietf-ternli 01
deleting charter-ietf-rtpsec 01
deleting charter-ietf-wae 01
deleting charter-ietf-sava 01
deleting charter-ietf-spkm 01
deleting charter-ietf-ifare 01
deleting charter-ietf-peppermint 01
deleting charter-ietf-hiccup 01
deleting charter-ietf-fsm 01
deleting charter-ietf-tools 01
deleting charter-ietf-proto 01
deleting charter-ietf-apm 01
deleting charter-ietf-nee 01
deleting charter-ietf-xsdmi 01
deleting charter-ietf-tam 01
deleting charter-ietf-biff 01
deleting charter-ietf-safe 01
deleting charter-ietf-rl2n 01
deleting charter-ietf-rucus 01
deleting charter-ietf-esds 01
deleting charter-ietf-tf 01
deleting charter-ietf-canmod 01
deleting charter-ietf-tana 01
deleting charter-ietf-ippm++ 01
deleting charter-ietf-pre8prob 01
deleting charter-ietf-netext2 01
deleting charter-ietf-intareawg 01
deleting charter-ietf-newprep 01
deleting charter-ietf-rydeirde 01
deleting charter-ietf-wgdtspec 01
deleting charter-ietf-e2md 01
deleting charter-ietf-fedauth 01
deleting charter-ietf-hasmat 01
deleting charter-ietf-iddtspec 01
deleting charter-ietf-nbs 01
deleting charter-ietf-lwip 01
deleting charter-ietf-scap 01
deleting charter-ietf-renum 01
deleting charter-ietf-plasma 01
deleting charter-ietf-dmm-proposed 01

deleting group tf

turning secdir into active group

turning ngdir into team
turning orad into team

turning nmarea into AG

turning aeiou into concluded BoF
turning cidr into concluded BoF
turning colip into concluded BoF
turning compen into concluded BoF
turning dlsw into concluded BoF
turning opmeas into concluded BoF
turning roamreq into concluded BoF
turning lamug into concluded BoF
turning dis into concluded BoF
turning dawg into concluded BoF
turning dnsfutur into concluded BoF
turning dns2 into concluded BoF
turning dnsbof into concluded BoF
turning dcnl into concluded BoF
turning mailreq into concluded BoF
turning eid into concluded BoF
turning opera into concluded BoF
turning earthen into concluded BoF
turning pages into concluded BoF
turning ftpftam into concluded BoF
turning gopher into concluded BoF
turning guts into concluded BoF
turning peering into concluded BoF
turning hops into concluded BoF
turning hostreq into concluded BoF
turning httpsec into concluded BoF
turning httpmib into concluded BoF
turning emailmgt into concluded BoF
turning check into concluded BoF
turning iia into concluded BoF
turning ipnni into concluded BoF
turning isfoo into concluded BoF
turning iwg into concluded BoF
turning ioh into concluded BoF
turning mib into concluded BoF
turning isn2 into concluded BoF
turning ipaddr into concluded BoF
turning ipacad into concluded BoF
turning hippi into concluded BoF
turning ngreqs into concluded BoF
turning 6bonebof into concluded BoF
turning nbmav6 into concluded BoF
turning lsthdr into concluded BoF
turning livdoc into concluded BoF
turning loip into concluded BoF
turning atmmib into concluded BoF
turning mboneng into concluded BoF
turning mbone into concluded BoF
turning msp into concluded BoF
turning mimecont into concluded BoF
turning mimereg into concluded BoF
turning pgpmime into concluded BoF
turning mmnet into concluded BoF
turning mplxmib into concluded BoF
turning napmime into concluded BoF
turning rtqos into concluded BoF
turning abby into concluded BoF
turning netgraph into concluded BoF
turning nttcp into concluded BoF
turning nosi into concluded BoF
turning newgen into concluded BoF
turning tcpng into concluded BoF
turning onc into concluded BoF
turning otsv into concluded BoF
turning omarea into concluded BoF
turning ositrans into concluded BoF
turning piara into concluded BoF
turning printjob into concluded BoF
turning prottest into concluded BoF
turning rtl into concluded BoF
turning realtime into concluded BoF
turning raidmib into concluded BoF
turning remmail into concluded BoF
turning rfc1006 into concluded BoF
turning rreqlist into concluded BoF
turning road into concluded BoF
turning rtgtbl into concluded BoF
turning tspatm into concluded BoF
turning select into concluded BoF
turning ssl into concluded BoF
turning whois into concluded BoF
turning skip into concluded BoF
turning smpframe into concluded BoF
turning smibof into concluded BoF
turning snapper into concluded BoF
turning snamib into concluded BoF
turning snmpagen into concluded BoF
turning sam into concluded BoF
turning devdisc into concluded BoF
turning snmpxns into concluded BoF
turning snmpseci into concluded BoF
turning mibcomp into concluded BoF
turning stif into concluded BoF
turning sofa into concluded BoF
turning tmux into concluded BoF
turning tcpfix into concluded BoF
turning teleconf into concluded BoF
turning telarch into concluded BoF
turning telnetlm into concluded BoF
turning testing into concluded BoF
turning tracerte into concluded BoF
turning trafchar into concluded BoF
turning ttcp into concluded BoF
turning tacit into concluded BoF
turning tcoord into concluded BoF
turning uribof into concluded BoF
turning url into concluded BoF
turning udi into concluded BoF
turning vac into concluded BoF
turning wais into concluded BoF
turning atminfo into concluded BoF
turning www into concluded BoF
turning polterm into concluded BoF
turning srp into concluded BoF
turning ieps into concluded BoF
turning cnhhttp into concluded BoF
turning ceot into concluded BoF
turning urp into concluded BoF
turning kwns into concluded BoF
turning saad into concluded BoF
turning hipbof into concluded BoF
turning sbsm into concluded BoF
turning letic into concluded BoF
turning rbridge into concluded BoF
turning urirev04 into concluded BoF
turning lowpan into concluded BoF
turning slrrp into concluded BoF
turning liaison into concluded BoF
turning callhome into concluded BoF
turning hoakey into concluded BoF
turning dmsp into concluded BoF
turning offpath into concluded BoF
turning ternli into concluded BoF
turning rtpsec into concluded BoF
turning wae into concluded BoF
turning sava into concluded BoF
turning spkm into concluded BoF
turning ifare into concluded BoF
turning peppermint into concluded BoF
turning hiccup into concluded BoF
turning fsm into concluded BoF
turning apm into concluded BoF
turning nee into concluded BoF
turning xsdmi into concluded BoF
turning biff into concluded BoF
turning safe into concluded BoF
turning rl2n into concluded BoF
turning rucus into concluded BoF
turning esds into concluded BoF
turning canmod into concluded BoF
turning tana into concluded BoF
turning ippmxx into concluded BoF
turning pre8prob into concluded BoF
turning netext2 into concluded BoF
turning intareawg into concluded BoF
turning newprep into concluded BoF
turning rydeirde into concluded BoF
turning wgdtspec into concluded BoF
turning fedauth into concluded BoF
turning hasmat into concluded BoF
turning iddtspec into concluded BoF
turning nbs into concluded BoF
turning lwip into concluded BoF
turning scap into concluded BoF
turning renum into concluded BoF
turning plasma into concluded BoF
turning dmm-proposed into concluded BoF

[ietf-svn-bot]

@rjsparks@nostrum.com changed milestone from Cleanup to Maintenance: Charters