Map NIST/FIPS and remove from this repo

ronaldtse commented 2 years ago

ronaldtse commented 2 years ago

mapping.yaml.zip

I was able to map these entries, but there are a number of them that are not available from the official NIST database.

---
reference.FIPS.1-1.1980.xml: NBS FIPS 1
reference.FIPS.113.1985.xml: NBS FIPS 113
reference.FIPS.146-1.1989.xml
reference.FIPS.146-1.1991.xml: NIST FIPS 146-1
reference.FIPS.146.1988.xml
reference.FIPS.146.1990.xml
reference.FIPS.161-1.1993.xml
reference.FIPS.180-1.1994.xml: NIST FIPS 180-1
reference.FIPS.180-1.1995.xml
reference.FIPS.180-2.2002.xml
reference.FIPS.180.1993.xml: NIST FIPS 180
reference.FIPS.186-1.1998.xml
reference.FIPS.186.1994.xml
reference.FIPS.197.2001.xml: NIST FIPS 197
reference.FIPS.35.1975.xml: NBS FIPS 35
reference.FIPS.4.1968.xml
reference.FIPS.46-1.1988.xml
reference.FIPS.46-2.1993.xml: NIST FIPS 46-2
reference.FIPS.46.1977.xml: NIST FIPS 46 (but this is 1990)
reference.FIPS.5-2.1987.xml: NBS FIPS 5-2
reference.FIPS.500-166.1989.xml: NBS SP 500-116 (but this is 1984)
reference.FIPS.500-20.1977.xml
reference.FIPS.500-61.1980.xml: NBS SP 500-61
reference.FIPS.55-2.1987.xml
reference.FIPS.58.1979.xml: NBS FIPS 58-1979
reference.FIPS.59.1979.xml: NBS FIPS 59
reference.FIPS.6-4.1990.xml: NIST FIPS 6-4
reference.FIPS.74.1981.xml: NBS FIPS 74
reference.FIPS.81.1980.xml: NBS FIPS 81
reference.FIPS.95-1.1993.xml: NBS FIPS 95-1
reference.FIPS.98.1983.xml: NBS FIPS 98
reference.NIST.500-162.1988.xml: NIST SP 500-162 (but this is 1989)
reference.NIST.500-162.1990.xml
reference.NIST.500-163.1989.xml: NIST SP 500-163
reference.NIST.500-166.1989.xml: NIST SP 500-166
reference.NIST.500-183.1990.xml: NIST SP 500-183 (but this is 1991)
reference.NIST.500-20.1977.xml: NBS SP 500-61 (but this is 1980)
reference.NIST.500-214.1993.xml
reference.NIST.500-61.1980.xml
reference.NIST.FIPS.202.xml: NIST FIPS 202
reference.NIST.SP.800-185.xml: NIST SP 800-185

Also posted to https://github.com/relaton/relaton-data-nist/issues/6

ronaldtse commented 2 years ago

As per https://github.com/relaton/relaton-data-nist/issues/6#issuecomment-1171453451 .

The resulting YAML mapping file is below:

---
reference.FIPS.1-1.1980.xml: NBS FIPS 1
reference.FIPS.113.1985.xml: NBS FIPS 113
reference.FIPS.146-1.1989.xml: fallback_unless_available(NIST FIPS 146)
reference.FIPS.146-1.1991.xml: NIST FIPS 146-1
reference.FIPS.146.1988.xml: fallback_unless_available(NIST FIPS 146)
reference.FIPS.146.1990.xml: NIST FIPS 146-1
reference.FIPS.161-1.1993.xml: fallback_unless_available(NIST FIPS 161-1)
reference.FIPS.180-1.1994.xml: NIST FIPS 180-1
reference.FIPS.180-1.1995.xml: NIST FIPS 180-1
reference.FIPS.180-2.2002.xml: fallback_unless_available(NIST FIPS 180-2)
reference.FIPS.180.1993.xml: NIST FIPS 180
reference.FIPS.186-1.1998.xml: fallback_unless_available(NIST FIPS 186-1)
reference.FIPS.186.1994.xml: NIST FIPS 186
reference.FIPS.197.2001.xml: NIST FIPS 197
reference.FIPS.35.1975.xml: NBS FIPS 35
reference.FIPS.4.1968.xml: fallback_unless_available(NBS FIPS 4)
reference.FIPS.46-1.1988.xml: fallback_unless_available(NBS 46-1)
reference.FIPS.46-2.1993.xml: NIST FIPS 46-2
reference.FIPS.46.1977.xml: fallback_unless_available(NBS 46)
reference.FIPS.5-2.1987.xml: NBS FIPS 5-2
reference.FIPS.500-166.1989.xml: NBS SP 500-166
reference.FIPS.500-20.1977.xml: fallback_unless_available(NBS SP 500-20)
reference.FIPS.500-61.1980.xml: NBS SP 500-61
reference.FIPS.55-2.1987.xml: fallback_unless_available(NBS FIPS 55-2)
reference.FIPS.58.1979.xml: NBS FIPS 58-1979
reference.FIPS.59.1979.xml: NBS FIPS 59
reference.FIPS.6-4.1990.xml: NIST FIPS 6-4
reference.FIPS.74.1981.xml: NBS FIPS 74
reference.FIPS.81.1980.xml: NBS FIPS 81
reference.FIPS.95-1.1993.xml: NBS FIPS 95-1
reference.FIPS.98.1983.xml: NBS FIPS 98
reference.NIST.500-162.1988.xml: NIST SP 500-162
reference.NIST.500-162.1990.xml: NIST SP 500-162
reference.NIST.500-163.1989.xml: NIST SP 500-163
reference.NIST.500-166.1989.xml: NIST SP 500-166
reference.NIST.500-183.1990.xml: NIST SP 500-183
reference.NIST.500-20.1977.xml: fallback_unless_available(NBS SP 500-20)
reference.NIST.500-214.1993.xml: fallback_unless_available(NIST SP 500-214)
reference.NIST.500-61.1980.xml: NBS SP 500-61
reference.NIST.FIPS.202.xml: NIST FIPS 202
reference.NIST.SP.800-185.xml: NIST SP 800-185

The syntax fallback_unless_available(...) means that the NIST data set does not have content right now, but when it does have them, the document identifiers provided as ... will be correct.

mapping.yaml.zip

strogonoff commented 2 years ago

@ronaldtse

When I run the mapping script, it complains that the paths in the mapping don’t exist in bibxml-data-archive.

Note that the mapping only applies to preexisting legacy xml2rfc paths—that is, paths in bibxml-data-archive.

If there’s no path in bibxml-data-archive, we can simply remove an entry from this dataset if it has an equivalent in another dataset. The entry will be available in GUI and using its new xml2rfc path.

Does that sound correct? I filed https://github.com/ietf-tools/relaton-data-misc/issues/9 to track this across other document types.

ietf-tools / relaton-data-misc

Map NIST/FIPS and remove from this repo #8