search

ietf-wg-dmarc / draft-ietf-dmarc-dmarcbis

5 stars 4 forks source link

DMARCbis WGLC: Description of psd=n #126

Closed toddherr closed 2 months ago

toddherr commented 6 months ago

As posted on list by Ale Vesely:

`Section 5.3, in the format description of psd:

   n:  The DMARC policy record is published for a PSD, but it is the
      Organizational Domain for itself and its subdomain.  There is
      no need to put psd=n in a DMARC record, except in the very
      unusual case of a parent PSD publishing a DMARC record without
      the requisite psd=y tag.

Perhaps a "not" is missing between "is" and "published"? I'd just say the domain is not a PSD /and/ it is the Organizational Domain for itself and its subdomain.`

jrlevine commented 6 months ago

Right, there's a missing 'not'

but it is not the Organizational Domain for itself or its subdomains.

toddherr commented 6 months ago

Change made and pushed to committed branch (rev-31)

toddherr commented 6 months ago

Reopening as there's still discussion occurring on-list

toddherr commented 2 months ago

Discussion ended; text now reflects consensus as the editor understands it.