search

ietf-wg-dnsop / draft-ietf-dnsop-avoid-fragmentation

0 stars 1 forks source link

Kucherawy COMMENT (1) #13

Open vixie opened 8 months ago

vixie commented 8 months ago

I support Rob Wilton's DISCUSS position. Piling on a bit, in reference to:

R6. UDP requestors SHOULD limit the requestor's maximum UDP payload size to the RECOMMENDED size of 1400 or a smaller size.

I think the "RECOMMENDED" here is just carrying forward a "RECOMMENDED" from someplace else. If that's correct, I suggest changing it to "recommended" or, if you want to be more precise, "... to the size recommended by RFCXXXX of 1400 or smaller." Now it's clear what the SHOULD is referencing, and you don't own the RECOMMENDED part here.

paulwouters commented 7 months ago

This was changed in my PR in response to various ballot requests.