search

ietf-wg-emailcore / emailcore

3 stars 0 forks source link

SMTP Registration template should have a field specifying level of approval #71

Closed aamelnikov closed 1 year ago

aamelnikov commented 1 year ago

John Klensin wrote:

Should we be distinguishing between extensions that are expected to be used generally and those that are expected to be for more private uses?

Alexey Melnikov wrote:

Possible options for the new field are "common"/"limited use", where "common" can only be used if the extension is documented in an IETF Stream document,

aamelnikov commented 1 year ago

The WG seems to have consensus around 2 registration models: IETF review and FCFS to just register keyword names to avoid conflicts. This issue is taken care of by the virtue of having 2 registration procedures and clear separation on IANA's website.