search

ietf-wg-emailcore / emailcore

3 stars 0 forks source link

Add Internationalization Considerations section to A/S #79

Open aamelnikov opened 1 year ago

aamelnikov commented 1 year ago

John Klensin wrote:

More broadly, while the EAI WG's extensions for non-ASCII headers and
addresses are explicitly out of scope for the EMAILCORE WG (at least
for 5321bis (and 5322bis), those documents make assumptions and
interpretations of the core documents.  Are there areas in which
5321bis could and should be clarified to lay a more solid foundation
for the EAI/SMTPUTF8 work and, if so, what are they?
toddherr commented 10 months ago

Are references to 653[01] that are already in A/S, along with pointers to MIME RFCs for internationalizing the contents of messages in the A/S sufficient. - Resnick, interim November 2023

Unlikely we have anything useful and new to say at this point. - Levine, interim November 2023

ksmurchison commented 3 months ago

Klensin 1 Dec, 2023:

Since I raised this issue initially to encourage others to think about it, I hope they will do so. However, in my own case, the number of issues about 5321bis and Alexey's "encouragement" to get 5321bis-22 out soon, means that I won't really be able to look at and think about the A/S until after 5321bis settles down and -22 is published. I hope that will be before 11 December, but the deadline is rather tight.