search

ietf-wg-ppm / draft-ietf-ppm-dap-taskprov

Define DAP extension for in-band task provisioning.
Other
2 stars 3 forks source link

Error type registration #34

Open divergentdave opened 1 year ago

divergentdave commented 1 year ago

The document currently suggests that the type urn:ietf:params:ppm:dap:error:invalidTask should be used in problem details responses. However, DAP says "Servers MUST NOT use the DAP URN namespace for errors not listed in the appropriate IANA registry". Thus, the taskprov document's 'IANA Considerations' section should either add an invalidTask entry to the contents of DAP's URN registry, or create a separate namespace of its own.

cjpatton commented 1 year ago

If/when this draft is adopted, I think we could make a case for extending the namespace. (i.e., say "extensions to DAP MAY extend the namespace"). In the meantime, I believe you're right.

wangshan commented 1 year ago

@divergentdave @cjpatton please suggest what should I do to fix this. Am I right it blocked by DAP section 8.3?

cjpatton commented 1 year ago

Let's hold this issue open until we get to WG call-for-adoption. If we discuss this at IETF 118, then I suggest bringing up the issue then.