Separate roles from actions

ietf-wg-scitt / draft-ietf-scitt-architecture

An Architecture for Trustworthy Digital Supply Chain Transparency Services

Other

11 stars 15 forks source link

Separate roles from actions #312

Closed SteveLasker closed 3 days ago

SteveLasker commented 4 days ago

From the editors call on 11/12/24

With the addition of the relying party roles, make the top consistent
Change the hanging text for sign/verify to actions
Move Issuer as the entity that performs the actions
Cleanup overly detailed row for COSE_SIGN1
Narrow the diagram to avoid make warnings

yogeshbdeshpande commented 4 days ago

in general the concept LGTM! For future: Just a word of caution: We should make every effort to make the Architecture, look simple. Too many boxes, complicate the diagram.

Also, any reason why you removed cose_sign1 It was super helpful to understand that the Signed Statement was cose_sign1

OR13 commented 4 days ago

@yogeshbdeshpande the reason was to keep the diagram high level, and leave details to spec text

henkbirkholz commented 3 days ago

Also, any reason why you removed cose_sign1 It was super helpful to understand that the Signed Statement was cose_sign1

As expected, but I would like to amplify Yogesh's question.

SteveLasker commented 3 days ago

As expected, but I would like to amplify Yogesh's question.

We did discuss this on the call, and @OR13 's comment sums up our conversation:

@henkbirkholz, are you blocking, or are you ok if we merge the current simplified version?

henkbirkholz commented 3 days ago

I am okay with the new version. We might apply of different meaning to the term "simplified" ☺️