ietf-wg-uuidrev / rfc4122bis

revision to RFC4122
Other
57 stars 11 forks source link

Clarify Hash Space IDs listed are not the only options #132

Closed danielmarschall closed 1 year ago

danielmarschall commented 1 year ago

It's probably too late for any amendments, so maybe it will only be an errata after publishing instead.

_Appendix B: This appendix lists the hash space IDs for use with UUIDv8 name-based UUIDs._ => The word "the" suggests that there can only be these hash space IDs and nothing else.

In comparison: Appendix A: This appendix lists the name space IDs for some potentially interesting name spaces => so appendix A implies that there can be many name space IDs.

My suggestion is that for Appendix B, remove the word "the" or replace it is "some", to imply that there can be other hash space IDs. (I guess this was your intention)

kyzer-davis commented 1 year ago

Yeah, I can sneak that in to my open PR.