ietf-wg-wimse / draft-ietf-wimse-s2s-protocol

WIMSE Service to Service I-D
Other
3 stars 3 forks source link

Verifying the "aud" claim of a WPT #26

Open yaronf opened 2 months ago

yaronf commented 2 months ago

Current text: "The aud claim of the WPT matches the target URI, or an acceptable alias or normalization thereof, of the HTTP request".

@yaronf: Man, what's a poor implementer to do with "an acceptable alias or normalization thereof"?

@bc-pi: Whatever they need to do to get shit to work in the case there are proxies in the middle that rewrite the path or even host. I agree that the language is less than ideal but think some allowance is needed.

https://github.com/yaronf/wimse-s2s/pull/19/files#r1648137394 for more context

arndt-s commented 1 month ago

Do we need audience if we have a good proof of possession coverage via other claims? 🤔

bc-pi commented 1 month ago

Do we need audience if we have a good proof of possession coverage via other claims? 🤔

Audience is, to the best of my always limited understanding, an integral part of that proof of possession coverage. No?